Files
SpaceCom/docs/Tenders/past tenders/tmp_pdf_extracts/QUANTAIR Proposal-SEP-211215087.txt

2838 lines
171 KiB
Plaintext
Raw Permalink Normal View History

=== PAGE 1 ===
Administrative forms
Page 1 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022
Call: HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03
(Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03)
Topic: HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03-WA1-3
Type of Action: HORIZON-JU-RIA
(HORIZON JU Research and Innovation Actions)
Proposal number: 101289612
Proposal acronym: QUANTAIR
Type of Model Grant Agreement: HORIZON Lump Sum Grant
Table of contents
Section Title Action
1 General information
2 Participants
3 Budget
4 Ethics and security
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 2 ===
Administrative forms
Page 2 of 33
Proposal ID 101289612
Acronym QUANTAIR
Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
1 - General information
Fields marked * are mandatory to fill.
Topic HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03-WA1-3
Type of Model Grant Agreement HORIZON-AG-LS
Type of Action HORIZON-JU-RIA
Call HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03
Acronym QUANTAIR
Proposal title Quantum Technologies for Airspace Innovation and Resilience
Note that for technical reasons, the following characters are not accepted in the Proposal Title and will be removed: < > " &
Duration in
months 24
Free keywords
Quantum Federated Learning, Quantum Machine Learning, Data Security, Privacy preservation, Demand Capacity
Balancing, ETOT optimisation, Improve Predictability of ATM operations
Abstract *
European air traffic management is becoming increasingly complex. The system now has to handle a growing variety of airspace
users — from hypersonic vehicles and high-altitude long-endurance platforms such as stratospheric balloons and HAPS, to
conventional subsonic flights. These vehicles often operate in overlapping altitude bands but have vastly different speeds, climb/
descent profiles, and manoeuvring capabilities.
At the same time, environmental policy drivers are stronger than ever. The EU Green Deal, ICAOs long-term aspirational goals, and
national climate strategies are pushing for measurable reductions in both CO₂ and non-CO₂ impacts, such as persistent contrails.
Resilience has also become a priority, with the network increasingly affected by severe weather, technical failures, and geopolitical
events that can close or restrict airspace at short notice.
One of the biggest technical challenges in all of these contexts is that many stakeholders — States, ANSPs, airlines, and defence
operators — cannot freely share operationally, privacy, or commercially sensitive data. Without that data, current modelling and
optimisation tools have to work with partial information, limiting their effectiveness.
Previous European research has already demonstrated that Federated Learning (FL) can bridge this gap, enabling accurate
predictions without requiring data to leave its origin. QUANTAIR proposes to take this further by pairing FL with quantum
optimisation — allowing us to integrate richer, privacy-protected data from multiple stakeholders, and then solve the resulting large-
scale, multi-variable problems at speeds suitable for operational decision-making.
Remaining characters 315
Has this proposal (or a very similar one) been submitted in the past 2 years in response to a call for
proposals under any EU programme, including the current call?
Yes No
Please give the proposal reference or contract number.
Previously submitted proposals should be with either 6 or 9 digits.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 3 ===
Administrative forms
Page 3 of 33
Proposal ID 101289612
Acronym QUANTAIR
Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Declarations
Field(s) marked * are mandatory to fill.
1) We declare to have the explicit consent of all applicants on their participation and on the content of this proposal. *
2) We confirm that the information contained in this proposal is correct and complete and that none of the project
activities have started before the proposal was submitted (unless explicitly authorised in the call conditions). *
3) We declare:
- to be fully compliant with the eligibility criteria set out in the call
- not to be subject to any exclusion grounds under the EU Financial Regulation 2018/1046
- to have the financial and operational capacity to carry out the proposed project. *
4) We acknowledge that all communication will be made through the Funding & Tenders Portal
electronic exchange system and that access and use of this system is subject to the Funding & Tenders Portal Terms
and Conditions. *
5) We have read, understood and accepted the Funding & Tenders Portal Terms & Conditions and
Privacy Statement that set out the conditions of use of the Portal and the scope, purposes, retention periods, etc. for
the processing of personal data of all data subjects whose data we communicate for the purpose of the application,
evaluation, award and subsequent management of our grant, prizes and contracts (including financial transactions and
audits). *
6) We declare that the proposal complies with ethical principles (including the highest standards of research integrity
as set out in the ALLEA European Code of Conduct for Research Integrity, as well as applicable international and
national law, including the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union and the European Convention on
Human Rights and its Supplementary Protocols. Appropriate procedures, policies and structures are in place to foster
responsible research practices, to prevent questionable research practices and research misconduct, and to handle
allegations of breaches of the principles and standards in the Code of Conduct. *
7) We declare that the proposal has an exclusive focus on civil applications (activities intended to be used in military
application or aiming to serve military purposes cannot be funded). If the project involves dual-use items in the sense
of Regulation 2021/821, or other items for which authorisation is required, we confirm that we will comply with the
applicable regulatory framework (e.g. obtain export/import licences before these items are used). *
8) We confirm that the activities proposed do not
- aim at human cloning for reproductive purposes;
- intend to modify the genetic heritage of human beings which could make such changes heritable
(with the exception of research relating to cancer treatment of the gonads, which may be financed), or
- intend to create human embryos solely for the purpose of research or for the purpose of stem
cell procurement, including by means of somatic cell nuclear transfer.
- lead to the destruction of human embryos (for example, for obtaining stem cells)
These activities are excluded from funding. *
9) We confirm that for activities carried out outside the Union, the same activities would have been allowed in at least
one EU Member State. *
10) For Lump Sum Grants with a detailed budget table: We understand and accept that the EU lump sum grants must
be reliable proxies for the actual costs of a project and confirm that the detailed budget for the proposal has been
established in accordance with our usual cost accounting practices and in compliance with the basic eligibility
conditions for EU actual cost grants (see AGA - Annotated Grant Agreement, art 6) and exclude costs that are ineligible
under the Programme. Purchases and subcontracting costs must be done taking into account best value for money
and must be free of conflict of interest. *
The coordinator is only responsible for the information relating to their own organisation. Each applicant remains responsible for the information declared for
their organisation. If the proposal is retained for EU funding, they will all be required to sign a declaration of honour.
False statements or incorrect information may lead to administrative sanctions under the EU Financial Regulation.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 4 ===
Administrative forms
Page 4 of 33
Proposal ID 101289612
Acronym QUANTAIR
Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
2 - Participants
List of participating organisations
# Participating Organisation Legal Name Country Role Action
1 DEUTSCHES ZENTRUM FUR LUFT - UND RAUMFAHRT EV Germany Coordinator
2 Qoro Quantum Ltd UK Partner
3 SkyNav Europe BE Partner
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 5 ===
Administrative forms
Page 5 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Organisation data
PIC
999981731
Legal name
DEUTSCHES ZENTRUM FUR LUFT - UND RAUMFAHRT EV
Short name: DLR
Address
Town KOLN
Postcode 51147
Street LINDER HOHE
Country Germany
Webpage www.dlr.de
Specific Legal Statuses
Legal person .......................................................... yes
Public body ............................................................ no
Non-profit ............................................................... yes
International organisation ...................................... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ...... no
Research organisation ........................................... yes
SME Data
Based on the below details from the Participant Registry the organisation is not an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
SME self-declared status ...................................... 03/01/2022 - no
SME self-assessment ........................................... unknown
SME validation ...................................................... 28/10/2008 - no
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 6 ===
Administrative forms
Page 6 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Departments carrying out the proposed work
Department 1
Department name Space Operations and Astronaut Training
Street Münchener Straße 20
Town Oberpfaffenhofen-Weßling
Same as proposing organisation's address
not applicable
Country Germany
Postcode 82234
Links with other participants
Type of link Participant
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 7 ===
Administrative forms
Page 7 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Main contact person
This will be the person the EU services will contact concerning this proposal (e.g. for additional information, invitation to hearings, sending of
evaluation results, convocation to start grant preparation). The data in blue is read-only. Details (name, first name and e-mail) of Main Contact
persons should be edited in the step "Participants" of the submission wizard.
First name* Andreas Last name* Spörl
E-Mail* andreas.spoerl@dlr.de
Town Oberpfaffenhofen-Weßling Post code 82234
Street Münchener Straße 20
Website Please enter website
Position in org. group lead
Department Space Operations and Astronaut Training
Phone +xxx xxxxxxxxx Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Gender Woman Man Non BinaryTitle Dr
Same as proposing organisation's address
Country Germany
Same as organisation
name
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Catharina Broocks catharina.broocks@dlr.de +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Sylvia Hutzschenreuter sylvia.hutzschenreuter@dlr.de +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Mirjam Kopp mirjam.kopp@dlr.de +xxx xxxxxxxxx
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 8 ===
Administrative forms
Page 8 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Researchers involved in the proposal
Title First Name Last Name Gender Nationality E-mail Career Stage
Role of
researcher (in
the project)
Reference
Identifier Type of identifier
Dr Andreas Spörl Man Germany andreas.spoerl@
dlr.de Category B Senior resea Leading 0009-0003-0727-
440X
Orcid ID
Ms Catharina Broocks Woman Germany catharina.broock
s@dlr.de
Category D First stage r Team member 0000-0002-4965-
1934
Orcid ID
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 9 ===
Administrative forms
Page 9 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Role of participating organisation in the project
Project management
Communication, dissemination and engagement
Provision of research and technology infrastructure
Co-definition of research and market needs
Civil society representative
Policy maker or regulator, incl. standardisation body
Research performer
Technology developer
Testing/validation of approaches and ideas
Prototyping and demonstration
IPR management incl. technology transfer
Public procurer of results
Private buyer of results
Finance provider (public or private)
Education and training
Contributions from the social sciences or/and the humanities
Other
If yes, please specify: (Maximum number of characters allowed: 50)
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 10 ===
Administrative forms
Page 10 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
List of up to 5 publications, widely-used datasets, software, goods, services, or any other achievements relevant to the call content.
Type of achievement Short description (Max 500 characters)
Publication
"Evolving Spacecraft Quantum On-Call Scheduling" (Prüfer S., Sajko W. et al (DLR),
SpaceOps-2023, ID 388) explores applying Grover's algorithm on quantum computers to
optimize a simplified operator shift scheduling problem at the German Space Operations
Center (GSOC). The study of this combinatorial optimization problem improves constraint
handling and achieves reduced gate costs of up to 90%. While focused on spacecraft, these
methods are also applicable to other scheduling tasks.
Publication
"QUARGS Quantum Reinforced Ground Station Scheduling" (Leidreiter D. A., Petrak A., et al
(DLR); SpaceOps-2025; ID 267) investigates the application of quantum computing to optimize
ground station scheduling for satellite operations. It introduces the QUARGS library that
utilizes quantum algorithms like QAOA, QA, VQE, and E-VQE. The study compares these
methods to classical solvers and addresses challenges in scalability and constraint
implementation.
Publication
“QEOPS Quantum Earth Observation Planning System” (Prüfer S., Anderle M. A. (DLR); IWPSS
2025) discusses a spacecraft mission planning use-case from the Quantum Mission Planning
Challenges (QMPC) project by the German Quantum Computing Initiative at DLR. It formalizes
the problem as an Integer Linear Programming (ILP) task, shares insights from applying
quantum computing, and compares early results between classical solvers and quantum
optimization algorithms.
Software
QUEASARS - Quantum Evolving Ansatz Variational Solver (Leidreiter D. A., Prüfer S. (DLR),
https://github.com/DLR-RB/QUEASARS) is an open-source, qiskit-based, python package
implementing quantum variational eigensolvers which use evolutionary algorithms to find a
good ansatz during the optimization process, like E-VQE, MoG-VQE or QNEAT. Currently only
EVQE is implemented.
List of up to 5 most relevant previous projects or activities, connected to the subject of this proposal.
Name of Project or Activity Short description (Max 500 characters)
QMPC
Quantum Mission Planning Challenges (QMPC) is a DLR QCI project (Nov<6F>2022Oct<63>2026)
developing quantum algorithms to solve real-world mission planning optimization problems
such as on call operator scheduling, ground station contact planning, and earth observation
acquisition for the German Space Operations Center (GSOC). It integrates hybrid and quantum
methods into GSOC workflows and extends to a Vehicle to Grid use case with the project
partner E.ON.
MuQuaNet
MuQuaNet (Munich Quantum Network) is a QKD-based quantum network in Munich,
enabling secure communication for research and government use. Within it, DLRs QSOC
integrates QKD into space operations by linking GSOC to the network and testing quantum-
encrypted data transmission. These efforts support future QKD-based space missions and
extend QSOC's role from quantum computing to secure quantum communication.
QAthMOS
QAthMOS (Quantum Telemetry and Health Monitoring System) is a QSOC led project aiming
to enhance satellite operations via quantum powered anomaly detection and predictive
analytics on telemetry data. It applies quantum machine learning techniques to monitor
satellite health, detect irregularities, and forecast issues—advancing the integration of
quantum technologies into operational spaceflight systems.
Description of any significant infrastructure and/or any major items of technical equipment, relevant to the proposed work.
Name of infrastructure of
equipment
Short description (Max 300 characters)
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 11 ===
Administrative forms
Page 11 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Quantum computers and
Simulators
Our connection to the DLR-QCI (Quantum Computing Initiative) allows access to a variety of
quantum computers and simulators based on different quantum hardware platforms. Small
scaled demo examples can therefore be computed and executed on actual quantum
hardware.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 12 ===
Administrative forms
Page 12 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Gender Equality Plan
Does the organization have a Gender Equality Plan (GEP) covering the elements listed below? Yes No
Minimum process-related requirements (building blocks) for a GEP
- Publication: formal document published on the institution's website and signed by the top management
- Dedicated resources: commitment of human resources and gender expertise to implement it.
- Data collection and monitoring: sex/gender disaggregated data on personnel (and students for establishments
concerned) and annual reporting based on indicators.
- Training: Awareness raising/trainings on gender equality and unconscious gender biases for staff and
decision-makers.
- Content-wise, recommended areas to be covered and addressed via concrete measures and targets are:
o work-life balance and organisational culture;
o gender balance in leadership and decision-making;
o gender equality in recruitment and career progression;
o integration of the gender dimension into research and teaching content;
o measures against gender-based violence including sexual harassment.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 13 ===
Administrative forms
Page 13 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
PIC
870017348
Legal name
Qoro Quantum Ltd
Short name: Qoro Quantum Ltd
Address
Town Harwell
Postcode OX11 0QX
Street R27 Atlas Building, Fermi Avenue,
Country United Kingdom
Webpage https://qoro.uk
Specific Legal Statuses
Legal person .......................................................... yes
Public body ............................................................ no
Non-profit ............................................................... no
International organisation ...................................... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ...... no
Research organisation ........................................... no
SME Data
Based on the below details from the Participant Registry the organisation is an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
SME self-declared status ...................................... 18/08/2025 - yes
SME self-assessment ........................................... unknown
SME validation ...................................................... unknown
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 14 ===
Administrative forms
Page 14 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Departments carrying out the proposed work
No department involved
Department name Name of the department/institute carrying out the work.
Street Please enter street name and number.
Town Please enter the name of the town.
Same as proposing organisation's address
not applicable
Country Please select a country
Postcode Area code.
Links with other participants
Type of link Participant
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 15 ===
Administrative forms
Page 15 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Main contact person
This will be the person the EU services will contact concerning this proposal (e.g. for additional information, invitation to hearings, sending of
evaluation results, convocation to start grant preparation). The data in blue is read-only. Details (name, first name and e-mail) of Main Contact
persons should be edited in the step "Participants" of the submission wizard.
First name* Stephen Last name* DiAdamo
E-Mail* stephen@qoroquantum.de
Town Harwell Post code OX11 0QX
Street R27 Atlas Building, Fermi Avenue,
Website www.qoroquantum.net
Position in org. CTO & Co-Founder
Department Qoro Quantum Ltd
Phone +4915254519041 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Gender Woman Man Non BinaryTitle Dr
Same as proposing organisation's address
Country United Kingdom
Same as organisation
name
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Dan Holme dan@qoro.uk +xxx xxxxxxxxx
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 16 ===
Administrative forms
Page 16 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Researchers involved in the proposal
Title First Name Last Name Gender Nationality E-mail Career Stage
Role of
researcher (in
the project)
Reference
Identifier Type of identifier
Dr Stephen DiAdamo Man Italy stephen@qoroqu
antum.uk Category B Senior resea Leading 0000-0001-5758-
9563
Orcid ID
Ms Amana Liaqat Woman United Kingdom amana@qoroqua
ntum.uk
Category C Recognised Team member
Mr Dan Holme Man United Kingdom dan@qoro.uk Category C Recognised Leading
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 17 ===
Administrative forms
Page 17 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Role of participating organisation in the project
Project management
Communication, dissemination and engagement
Provision of research and technology infrastructure
Co-definition of research and market needs
Civil society representative
Policy maker or regulator, incl. standardisation body
Research performer
Technology developer
Testing/validation of approaches and ideas
Prototyping and demonstration
IPR management incl. technology transfer
Public procurer of results
Private buyer of results
Finance provider (public or private)
Education and training
Contributions from the social sciences or/and the humanities
Other
If yes, please specify: (Maximum number of characters allowed: 50)
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 18 ===
Administrative forms
Page 18 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
List of up to 5 publications, widely-used datasets, software, goods, services, or any other achievements relevant to the call content.
Type of achievement Short description (Max 500 characters)
Publication
"QAOA in Quantum Datacenters: Parallelization, Simulation, and Orchestration." 2025 IEEE
International Conference on Quantum Software, 2025. Introduces Qoros architecture for
automated quantum software execution across distributed computing networks.
Demonstrates orchestration strategies that parallelize workloads and allocate resources
dynamically, critical foundations for federated quantum computing.
Publication
"Practical quantum k-means clustering: Performance analysis and applications in energy grid
classification." IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering 3, 2022. Demonstrates hardware-
aware quantum machine learning methods, showing performance gains when hardware
constraints are integrated into software design. Provides evidence for scaling machine
learning and optimization workloads over heterogeneous quantum-classical infrastructures.
Publication
"Quantum algorithms and simulation for parallel and distributed quantum computing." 2021
IEEE/ACM Second International Workshop on Quantum Computing Software. IEEE, 2021.
Presents a software framework for parallel execution of quantum algorithms across clusters.
Lays groundwork for distributed execution models, including federated approaches used in
this project.
Software
Qoro's Divi. Divi is a Python-based software development kit that builds and parallelizes
quantum programs. It partitions tasks and transmits them to distributed compute resources
through Composer, enabling large-scale workloads such as optimization and machine
learning. It supports hybrid execution, key to federated computing.
Software
Qoro's Composer. Composer is a scheduling and orchestration engine that dynamically selects
resources for distributed workloads. It evaluates real-time network and device conditions to
route jobs efficiently, forming the backbone of federated learning and computation in hybrid
HPC-quantum environments.
List of up to 5 most relevant previous projects or activities, connected to the subject of this proposal.
Name of Project or Activity Short description (Max 500 characters)
ESA Business Incubation
Selected for ESAs incubation program, Qoro applied Divi and Composer to satellite
communications optimization. Demonstrated distributed computing and task partitioning
over satellite constellations, proving the scalability and adaptability of our approach for
mission-critical environments.
Pilot projects with HPC centers
In partnership with CESGA, we deployed Composer to orchestrate quantum-classical
workloads over HPC nodes, integrating security and scheduling for multi-node execution. This
work validated interoperability across heterogeneous systems and demonstrated scaling
strategies relevant to air traffic management.
Pilot projects with Enterprise
Collaborated with enterprise partners (e.g., E.ON, Multiverse Computing) to integrate Divi into
energy and finance workflows. Showcased parallelization and partitioning of real-world
optimization problems over hybrid clusters, demonstrating readiness to bring federated
models to complex industries.
Description of any significant infrastructure and/or any major items of technical equipment, relevant to the proposed work.
Name of infrastructure of
equipment
Short description (Max 300 characters)
Qoro's cloud computing service
A scalable cloud platform hosting Qoros distributed orchestration stack, enabling
deployment, benchmarking, and execution of federated quantum-classical workloads across
multiple sites.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 19 ===
Administrative forms
Page 19 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Qoro's GPU-based quantum
simualator
High-performance GPU-accelerated simulator for quantum circuits, optimized for batch
execution and hybrid workflows, enabling realistic modeling of large-scale federated
computing scenarios.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 20 ===
Administrative forms
Page 20 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Gender Equality Plan
Does the organization have a Gender Equality Plan (GEP) covering the elements listed below? Yes No
Minimum process-related requirements (building blocks) for a GEP
- Publication: formal document published on the institution's website and signed by the top management
- Dedicated resources: commitment of human resources and gender expertise to implement it.
- Data collection and monitoring: sex/gender disaggregated data on personnel (and students for establishments
concerned) and annual reporting based on indicators.
- Training: Awareness raising/trainings on gender equality and unconscious gender biases for staff and
decision-makers.
- Content-wise, recommended areas to be covered and addressed via concrete measures and targets are:
o work-life balance and organisational culture;
o gender balance in leadership and decision-making;
o gender equality in recruitment and career progression;
o integration of the gender dimension into research and teaching content;
o measures against gender-based violence including sexual harassment.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 21 ===
Administrative forms
Page 21 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
PIC
870906450
Legal name
SkyNav Europe
Short name: SkyNav Europe
Address
Town Brussels
Postcode 1000
Street Rue Coppens 16
Country Belgium
Webpage www.skynavintl.com
Specific Legal Statuses
Legal person .......................................................... yes
Public body ............................................................ no
Non-profit ............................................................... no
International organisation ...................................... no
Secondary or Higher education establishment ...... no
Research organisation ........................................... no
SME Data
Based on the below details from the Participant Registry the organisation is an SME (small- and medium-sized enterprise) for the call.
SME self-declared status ...................................... 27/09/2024 - yes
SME self-assessment ........................................... 27/09/2024 - yes
SME validation ...................................................... unknown
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 22 ===
Administrative forms
Page 22 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Departments carrying out the proposed work
No department involved
Department name Name of the department/institute carrying out the work.
Street Please enter street name and number.
Town Please enter the name of the town.
Same as proposing organisation's address
not applicable
Country Please select a country
Postcode Area code.
Links with other participants
Type of link Participant
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 23 ===
Administrative forms
Page 23 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Main contact person
This will be the person the EU services will contact concerning this proposal (e.g. for additional information, invitation to hearings, sending of
evaluation results, convocation to start grant preparation). The data in blue is read-only. Details (name, first name and e-mail) of Main Contact
persons should be edited in the step "Participants" of the submission wizard.
First name* Ben Last name* Kings
E-Mail* ben.kings@skynavintl.com
Town Brussels Post code 1000
Street Rue Coppens 16
Website https://skynavintl.com/
Position in org. Managing Director/Owner
Department SkyNav Europe
Phone +31615625092 Phone 2 +xxx xxxxxxxxx
Gender Woman Man Non BinaryTitle Mr
Same as proposing organisation's address
Country Belgium
Same as organisation
name
Other contact persons
First Name Last Name E-mail Phone
Duncan Auld duncan.auld@skynavintl.com +xxx xxxxxxxxx
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 24 ===
Administrative forms
Page 24 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Researchers involved in the proposal
Title First Name Last Name Gender Nationality E-mail Career Stage
Role of
researcher (in
the project)
Reference
Identifier Type of identifier
Mr Ben Kings Man ben.kings@skyna
vintl.com Category A Top grade reLeading
Mr Duncan Auld Man duncan.auld@sky
navintl.com
Category A Top grade reLeading
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 25 ===
Administrative forms
Page 25 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Role of participating organisation in the project
Project management
Communication, dissemination and engagement
Provision of research and technology infrastructure
Co-definition of research and market needs
Civil society representative
Policy maker or regulator, incl. standardisation body
Research performer
Technology developer
Testing/validation of approaches and ideas
Prototyping and demonstration
IPR management incl. technology transfer
Public procurer of results
Private buyer of results
Finance provider (public or private)
Education and training
Contributions from the social sciences or/and the humanities
Other
If yes, please specify: (Maximum number of characters allowed: 50)
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 26 ===
Administrative forms
Page 26 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
List of up to 5 publications, widely-used datasets, software, goods, services, or any other achievements relevant to the call content.
Type of achievement Short description (Max 500 characters)
Service
Operational ATM experience
Decades of global, operational Air Traffic Control experience across all ATC disciplines (Tower,
Approach, Area, Oceanic) and at all function levels. Operational supervision, flow
management, training, training management, safety and technical committee
representation, operational procedure development, international cross-border negotiations,
airspace design, safety risk assessments and environmental impact studies
Service
Project Management & Leadership Expertise
Extensive track record in project and organisational leadership, including executive roles
within IFATCA (International Federation of Air Traffic Controllers Associations). Demonstrated
ability to manage complex international initiatives, coordinate diverse stakeholders, and
oversee multi-million-euro budgets. Proven experience in steering strategic aviation projects,
ensuring delivery of innovative outcomes aligned with European policy & industry need
Service
ECHO2 subcontractor
Participation in the ECHO2 consortium as a contractor focusing on higher airspace and space
transport integration. Contributions include operational concept refinement, validation
planning, stakeholder mapping, and alignment with ANSP procedures and Network functions.
The work informs scalable approaches for trajectory management and airspace reservations.
Includes project management and deliverable lead.
Service
ICAO drafting and representation
Contributed to drafting and review activities at ICAO in relation to Annex 11, Annex 10 and
PANS-ATM material. Work includes requirements structuring, procedure text, and consistency
checks across datasets and guidance, supporting globally harmonised ATM provisions
relevant to STO and HAO integration. Leading working groups on ATM planning &
implementation, development of Global ATM Operational Concept, development of Aviation
System Block Upgrades
Service
State regulatory drafting and representation
Several years of regulatory drafting support for a Gulf State authority, updating national civil
aviation regulations, AMC/GM-style guidance and implementation procedures across ANS,
operations and oversight. Emphasis on practicality, traceability and alignment with ICAO and
regional provisions. Leadership of ICAO regional groups and task forces related to integration
of space transport activities.
List of up to 5 most relevant previous projects or activities, connected to the subject of this proposal.
Name of Project or Activity Short description (Max 500 characters)
SESAR ECHO / ECHO2 HAO
Integration
Participation in ECHO and ECHO2 on higher airspace and space transport integration. Roles
covered operational scenarios, requirements traceability, validation planning, stakeholder
engagement and alignment with EUROCONTROL and ICAO practices for cross-border
coordination and dynamic, minimal-impact airspace management.
iNEO Project Management Plan
& Governance Appr.
Development of a rigorous PMP and governance model for multi-partner R&D, covering
schedule baselining, risk and compliance, quality assurance, and reporting. The approach
underpins efficient WP coordination and is directly reusable for other HORIZON projects.
UAE National Regulations
Development Programme
Regulatory drafting support for a Gulf State authority, updating national civil aviation
regulations, AMC/GM-style guidance and implementation procedures across ANS, operations
and oversight. Emphasis on practicality, traceability and alignment with ICAO and regional
provisions.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 27 ===
Administrative forms
Page 27 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Description of any significant infrastructure and/or any major items of technical equipment, relevant to the proposed work.
Name of infrastructure of
equipment Short description (Max 300 characters)
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 28 ===
Administrative forms
Page 28 of 33 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Gender Equality Plan
Does the organization have a Gender Equality Plan (GEP) covering the elements listed below? Yes No
Minimum process-related requirements (building blocks) for a GEP
- Publication: formal document published on the institution's website and signed by the top management
- Dedicated resources: commitment of human resources and gender expertise to implement it.
- Data collection and monitoring: sex/gender disaggregated data on personnel (and students for establishments
concerned) and annual reporting based on indicators.
- Training: Awareness raising/trainings on gender equality and unconscious gender biases for staff and
decision-makers.
- Content-wise, recommended areas to be covered and addressed via concrete measures and targets are:
o work-life balance and organisational culture;
o gender balance in leadership and decision-making;
o gender equality in recruitment and career progression;
o integration of the gender dimension into research and teaching content;
o measures against gender-based violence including sexual harassment.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 29 ===
Administrative forms
Page 29 of 33
Proposal ID 101289612
Acronym QUANTAIR
Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
3 - Budget
No Name of Beneficiary Country Role Requested grant
amount
Income generated
by the action
Financial
contributions
Own resources Total estimated
income
1 Deutsches Zentrum Fur Luft - Und Raumfahrt Ev DE Coordinator 167 350.00 0 0 0 167 350.00
2 Qoro Quantum Ltd UK Partner 435 086.16 0 0 20 000 455 086.16
3 Skynav Europe BE Partner 342 890.63 0 0 0 342 890.63
Total 945 326.79 20 000
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 30 ===
Administrative forms
Page 30 of 33
Proposal ID 101289612
Acronym QUANTAIR
Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
4 - Ethics & security
Ethics Issues Table
1. Human Embryonic Stem Cells and Human Embryos Page
Does this activity involve Human Embryonic Stem Cells (hESCs)? Yes No
Does this activity involve the use of human embryos? Yes No
2. Humans Page
Does this activity involve human participants? Yes No
Does this activity involve interventions (physical also including imaging technology,
behavioural treatments, etc.) on the study participants? Yes No
Does this activity involve conducting a clinical study as defined by the Clinical Trial Regulation
(EU 536/2014)? (using pharmaceuticals, biologicals, radiopharmaceuticals, or advanced
therapy medicinal products)
Yes No
3. Human Cells / Tissues (not covered by section 1) Page
Does this activity involve the use of human cells or tissues? Yes No
4. Personal Data Page
Does this activity involve processing of personal data? Yes No
Does this activity involve further processing of previously collected personal data (including
use of preexisting data sets or sources, merging existing data sets)?
Yes No
Is it planned to export personal data from the EU to non-EU countries? Yes No
Is it planned to import personal data from non-EU countries into the EU or from a non-EU
country to another non-EU country?
Yes No
Does this activity involve the processing of personal data related to criminal convictions or
offences?
Yes No
5. Animals Page
Does this activity involve animals? Yes No
6. Non-EU Countries Page
Will some of the activities be carried out in non-EU countries? Yes No 0
United Kingdom
In case non-EU countries are involved, do the activities undertaken in these countries raise
potential ethics issues? Yes No
It is planned to use local resources (e.g. animal and/or human tissue samples, genetic material,
live animals, human remains, materials of historical value, endangered fauna or flora samples,
etc.)?
Yes No
Is it planned to import any material (other than data) from non-EU countries into the EU or
from a non-EU country to another non-EU country? For data imports, see section 4. Yes No
Is it planned to export any material (other than data) from the EU to non-EU countries? For
data exports, see section 4. Yes No
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 31 ===
Administrative forms
Page 31 of 33
Proposal ID 101289612
Acronym QUANTAIR
Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Does this activity involve low and/or lower middle income countries, (if yes, detail the benefit-
sharing actions planned in the self-assessment) Yes No
Could the situation in the country put the individuals taking part in the activity at risk? Yes No
7. Environment, Health and Safety Page
Does this activity involve the use of substances or processes that may cause harm to the
environment, to animals or plants.(during the implementation of the activity or further to the
use of the results, as a possible impact) ?
Yes No
Does this activity deal with endangered fauna and/or flora / protected areas? Yes No
Does this activity involve the use of substances or processes that may cause harm to humans,
including those performing the activity.(during the implementation of the activity or further
to the use of the results, as a possible impact) ?
Yes No
8. Artificial Intelligence Page
Does this activity involve the development, deployment and/or use of Artificial Intelligence-
based systems? Yes No 0
9. Other Ethics Issues Page
Are there any other ethics issues that should be taken into consideration? Yes No
I confirm that I have taken into account all ethics issues above and that, if any ethics issues apply, I will complete the
ethics self-assessment as described in the guidelines How to Complete your Ethics Self-Assessment
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 32 ===
Administrative forms
Page 32 of 33
Proposal ID 101289612
Acronym QUANTAIR
Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Ethics Self-Assessment
Ethical dimension of the objectives, methodology and likely impact
6. Non-EU Countries
Will some of the activities be carried out in non-EU countries?
Parts of the research is carried out in UK. The work is of documentary type.
No impacts and/or misuses on environment, social or political groups are expected.
8. Artificial intelligence
Does this activity involve the development, deployment and/or use of Artificial Intelligence-based systems?
Yes, first for text generation and second, because the project elaborates on concepts (quantum) machine learning approaches.
Remaining characters 4491
Compliance with ethical principles and relevant legislations
6. Non-EU Countries
Due to the involvement of UK as non-EU country, the project confirms compliance to the highest ethical standards.
All research conducted (in either EU Memberstates or UK) will be of legal type in all mentioned countries.
8. Artificial intelligence
QUANTAIRs actively integrates privacy, safety, fairness, environmental responsibility, dual-use safeguards, and transparency into its
objectives. Wherever AI is used, it only contributes as a prelimenary step for further verfication.
Remaining characters 4492
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 33 ===
Administrative forms
Page 33 of 33
Proposal ID 101289612
Acronym QUANTAIR
Horizon Europe ver 1.00 20241022 Last saved 17/09/2025 06:50
Security issues table
1. EU Classified Information (EUCI)2 Page
Does this activity involve information and/or materials requiring protection against
unauthorised disclosure (EUCI)? Yes No
Does this activity involve non-EU countries which need to have access to EUCI? Yes No
2. Misuse Page
Does this activity have the potential for misuse of results? Yes No
3. Other Security Issues Page
Does this activity involve information and/or materials subject to national security restrictions?
If yes, please specify: (Maximum number of characters allowed: 1000)
Yes No
Are there any other security issues that should be taken into consideration?
If yes, please specify: (Maximum number of characters allowed: 1000)
Yes No
Security self-assessment
(No Security Issue was marked with Yes)
Remaining characters 4961
2According to the Commission Decision (EU, Euratom) 2015/444 of 13 March 2015 on the security rules for protecting EU classified information, “European Union
classified information (EUCI) means any information or material designated by an EU security classification, the unauthorised disclosure of which could cause varying
degrees of prejudice to the interests of the European Union or of one or more of the Member States”.
3Classified background information is information that is already classified by a country and/or international organisation and/or the EU and is going to be used by the
project. In this case, the project must have in advance the authorisation from the originator of the classified information, which is the entity (EU institution, EU Member
State, third state or international organisation) under whose authority the classified information has been generated.
4EU classified foreground information is information (documents/deliverables/materials) planned to be generated by the project and that needs to be protected from
unauthorised disclosure. The originator of the EUCI generated by the project is the European Commission.
This proposal version was submitted by Andreas Spörl on 16/09/2025 11:51:52 Brussels Local Time. Issued by the Funding & Tenders Portal Submission System.
=== PAGE 34 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 1 of 50
Proposal template Part B: technical description
QUANTAIR
[This document is tagged. Do not delete the tags; they are needed for processing.] #@APP-FORM-HERIAIA@#
List of participants
Participant No. * Participant organisation name Country
1 (Coordinator) Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt (DLR e.V.) Germany
2 Qoro Quantum United Kingdom
3 SkyNav International Belgium
1. Excellence #@REL-EVA-RE@#
1.1 Objectives and ambition #@PRJ-OBJ-PO@#
QUANTAIR investigates the feasibility of applying Quantum Federated machine Learning (QFL) to Air Traffic
Management (ATM) at TRL 1. Federated Machine Learning (FedML) is a distributed approach in which models are
trained across multiple independent data sources without requiring the exchange of raw data. This is of clear relevance
to ATM, where operational datasets are fragmented across various stakeholders such as airlines, ANSPs, airports,
and regulators, and where data protection, confidentiality, and sovereignty considerations prevent centralisation.
Quantum computing is still at an early stage and cannot yet be used in operational systems. However, research in
other fields suggests that certain quantum algorithms can eventually provide advantages when dealing with very large
or complex problems, such as those involving many interdependent variables [1]. FedML, by contrast, is already a
recognised approach that allows different stakeholders to train models collaboratively without sharing their raw data
[2]. In QUANTAIR, the focus is on exploring the feasibility of combining FedML with the capabilities of Quantum
computing for ATM at TRL 1.
The project aims to provide the first structured assessment of QFL for ATM. Its contribution is not the development
of prototypes or operational tools, but rather the creation of a conceptual and methodological foundation on which
future SESAR research can build. QUANTAIR clarifies whether QFL represents a promising research direction for
ATM, defines the conditions under which it might deliver benefits, estimates quantum resources, and identifies the
steps required to advance to TRL 23. The previous work by EUROCONTROL for the SESAR programme, called
AICHAIN [3], proved that classical federated learning (FL) can improve ATM predictions such as ETOT and route
forecasting without requiring sensitive data to be centralised. This showed clear value in applying FedML to
fragmented, confidential datasets across airline s, ANSPs, and airports. However, classical FedML faces limits as
ATM problems grow in size and complexity. Multi-flight trajectory optimisation, higher airspace operations, contrail
modelling, and large -scale disruption management create exponential decisi on spaces and high -dimensional data
where classical methods struggle.
QFL offers a pathway beyond these constraints. Quantum machine learning and sampling techniques could improve
scalability and trainability, speed up convergence, and capture correlations that classical FedML may miss [4]. They
also enable richer modelling of rare but safety -critical events, strengthening resilience. The benefit is twofold:
immediate applicability through privacy-preserving FedML, and long-term potential to exploit quantum acceleration
once hardware matures. This positions QFL as both a natu ral evolution of AICHAINs work and a future -proofed
approach aligned with SESARs digital and green ATM priorities [5]. By targeting ATM, the project provides a
=== PAGE 35 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 2 of 50
demanding testbed for QFL. ATM data is fragmented across many stakeholders, highly sensitive, and time-critical,
which pushes QFL beyond simpler academic demonstrations. Developing the ATM use cases will expose how QFL
copes with heterogeneous datasets, pr ivacy constraints, and multi -objective optimisation. These lessons will be
transferable to other sectors that face similar challenges, such as energy grids, healthcare networks, or logistics chains
[1]. The project also clarifies where quantum methods add value beyond classical FL, for example in scaling federated
models, simulating rare events, or solving complex optimisation problems. In doing so, it creates benchmarks,
reference architectures, and research roadmaps that the wider QFL community can build upon. The outputs therefore
go beyond ATM: they define generic methods, highlight open technical questions, and establish a foundation for
advancing QFL across domains.
To achieve the project objectives, the work is organised around four Exploratory Cases, each representing a distinct
ATM challenge.
• PREDICT (Privacy-Respecting Enhanced Departure Integration with Coordinated Timing ) focuses
on departure predictability and slot allocation. Today, flight departure times are subject to frequent
uncertainty, creating knock -on effects for network efficiency and traffic flow management. The case
investigates whether federated models train ed across multiple stakeholders could improve A -CDM
performance in areas such as estimate accuracy (Estimated Take-Off Time (ETOT), Target Take-Off Time
(TTOT), etc.) and CTOT regula tion application (supporting the SESAR goal of reduced CTOT allocation
through 4D trajectory management), without requiring the sharing of commercially sensitive data.
• HORIQON (High-altitude Operations with Real -time Integrated Quantum -Optimised Navigation)
examines trajectory planning and integration in higher airspace. As new entrants, such as high -altitude
platforms and space transport operations, begin to interact with conventional aviation, new methods will be
required to manage trajectories where littl e operational data currently exists. The case explores how QFL
could enable collaborative modelling of such trajectories in a way that protects sensitive data and supp orts
safe integration.
• SHIELD (Strengthened Handling of Irregular Events and Landing Diversions) addresses diversion
capacity and network resilience. Disruptions such as weather, technical failures, or security incidents often
require diversions, but the available diversion capacity across the network is not always visible to all actors.
This case considers whether QFL could allow stakeholders to model and share diversion capacity information
without exposing sensitive or commercially confidential data, improving the networks ability to respond to
disruptions.
• CONTRADE (Climate-Optimised Navigation for TRAjectory DEsign) investigates contrail prediction
to support environmentally optimised planning. Avoiding persistent contrails is recognised as a key measure
for reducing the climate impact of aviation, but predicting where contrails will form requires combining data
from multiple sources. The case explores whether QFL could be used to generate contrail risk maps
collaboratively, improving environmental outcomes while respecting data ownership and privacy.
PREDICT focuses on operational efficiency and network capacity. HORIQON addresses the integration of new
entrants such as high-altitude and space transport operations. SHIELD responds to the need for resilience in the face
of disruption. CONTRADE tackles e nvironmental sustainability by examining contrail avoidance strategies.
Together, they demonstrate how QFL could be applicable to very different aspects of the ATM system rather than
concentrating on a single narrow problem.
Together, these cases ensure that the research addresses operational efficiency, integration of new entrants, resilience,
and sustainability. They provide representative contexts for assessing QFL concepts at TRL 1, without moving into
prototyping or operational validation. They were chosen to ensure that results are relevant across the breadth of the
European ATM Master Plan.
=== PAGE 36 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 3 of 50
QUANTAIR sets out to achieve the following objectives:
1. Investigate whether FedML is conceptually applicable to ATM problems, while also considering where
quantum methods might support its scalability.
• The first objective is to determine the feasibility of applying QFL to representative ATM challenges.
This involves examining whether distributed learning methods can be adapted to the constraints of
ATM, such as heterogeneous data sources, privacy restric tions, and operational time -criticality. It
also considers whether quantum techniques could, in future, play a role in scaling these methods to
larger or more complex problems. The outcome will be a feasibility analysis supported by conceptual
models and indicators.
2. Develop high-level frameworks for QFL in each Exploratory Case.
• Each of the four cases is chosen to represent a distinct ATM challenge. For each case, the project
will develop a conceptual framework describing how QFL could be applied, what the learning
architecture might look like, what kinds of data would be needed, and how results could support
operational decision-making. These frameworks will be high -level and exploratory, but they will
provide a structured representation that can be taken forward in subsequent research.
3. Identify potential benefits, limitations, and open research questions.
• The third objective is to move beyond purely speculative discussion by systematically assessing both
advantages and drawbacks. Potential benefits may include improved predictability, resilience, or
environmental outcomes. Limitations may relate to data qua lity, computational constraints, or
explainability of the models. Open questions may include how federated models could be validated
in a safety -critical environment or how quantum methods could be integrated when hardware
becomes more mature. The identification of such gaps is itself a valuable outcome, as it directs future
SESAR work towards areas of highest relevance.
4. Define the steps needed to advance this research to TRL 23 in future work.
• Finally, the project aims to provide a roadmap for subsequent SESAR research. This includes
identifying the data -sharing frameworks, modelling techniques, and validation approaches that
would be required for TRL 23 studies. It also considers how and when quantum machine learning
methods might become relevant. This ensures that the projects outputs are not isolated academic
results but are directly linked to the SESAR innovation pipeline.
QUANTAIR responds directly to the scope of HORIZON -SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03-WA1-3 by investigating the
application of quantum computing methods to ATM. At TRL 1, the emphasis is placed on federated learning
approaches and their conceptual integration into ATM, while also identifying where quantum machine learning could
in future support scalability. The objectives are realistic within a TRL 1 framework and are measurable through
conceptual indicators such as model fidelity, scalability analysis, and qualitative assessment of potential benefits. In
doing so, the project provides a structured contribution to the SESAR Master Plans long-term vision of the Digital
European Sky and the research priorities set out in the Work Programme.
In terms of ambition and positioning, QUANTAIR fills a critical research gap. FedML has been explored in limited
ways within aviation, mostly for localised applications such as airport processes or isolated ANSP datasets. There
has been no systematic investigation of whether these techniques could be scaled across the network or used in multi-
stakeholder settings where privacy and sovereignty concerns prevent centralised data sharing. Similarly, while
quantum computing research is advancing rapidly, applications to ATM have not yet been explored. QUANTAIR is
therefore the first structured attempt to bring all of the previous research initiatives together into a tangible plan for
development towards future ATM solutions beyond TRL 3.
The project targets TRL 1 and does not intend to develop prototypes, demonstrators, or operational tools. Its ambition
lies instead in being the first project to provide a structured assessment of QFL in holistic ATM, grounded in
representative use cases, and linked to SESARs strategic objectives. The outputs will be conceptual frameworks,
feasibility analyses, and roadmaps that guide the next phase of research. This ensures that the project is both realistic
in its scope and ambitious in its contribution, establishing a research direction that could shape European ATM
innovation for the next decade.
=== PAGE 37 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 4 of 50
#§PRJ-OBJ-PO§#
1.2 Methodology #@CON-MET-CM@# #@COM-PLE-CP@#
FedML is a machine-learning approach in which models are trained collaboratively across distributed data sources
without the need to pool raw data in a central repository. This is relevant to ATM, where operational data is
fragmented between stakeholders (such as airlines, ANSPs, airports, and regulators) and where concerns over
privacy, sovereignty, and commercial sensitivity prevent centralisation. By allowing stakeholders to contribute to
shared models without releasing their raw data, FedML provides a potential way of overcoming these barriers.
In defining the methodology, QUANTAIR focuses on the use of quantum computing as a conceptual analysis. The
project is scoped at TRL 1 not due to a lack of capability, but because current quantum hardware is not yet sufficiently
mature to enable higher -TRL validation in ATM. QUANTAIR therefore focuses on conceptual feasibility while
identifying the pathways that can be pursued once the technology advances. The research examines how federated
learning frameworks in ATM could, in principle, benefit from quant um methods for future TRLs, particularly in
handling large-scale optimisation and high-dimensional learning tasks. This ensures the project remains grounded in
what is achievable at TRL 1, while establishing a forward-looking research pathway relevant to SESARs long-term
ambitions.
In QUANTAIR, QFL[DS1] is defined as the use of federated learning to enable distributed model training across
ATM stakeholders, combined with an explicit recognition of the potential role of quantum methods in future TRLs.
The research is not intended to deliver operational tools but to establish whether this approach is feasible and useful
in an ATM context.
The methodology is based on several assumptions. It assumes that relevant data is distributed across multiple
stakeholders, that this data varies in quality and format, and that privacy and sovereignty concerns will prevent full
centralisation. It assumes that local training and global aggregation can be adapted to ATM use cases, and that
scalability may require quantum-enabled methods in future TRLs. These assumptions frame the scope of the work
and define the limits of the feasibility analysis.
This conceptual basis is well suited to the projects objectives. The aim is not to deliver prototypes but to investigate
feasibility, develop high-level frameworks, identify potential benefits and limitations, and define pathways towards
higher-TRL research. FedML provides the structure for exploring distributed collaboration in ATM, and quantum
computing offers a forward-looking perspective that connects the work to the long-term vision of SESAR.
FedML is a machine-learning approach in which models are trained collaboratively across distributed data sources
without the need to pool raw data in a central repository. This is relevant to ATM, where operational data is
fragmented between stakeholders ( such as airlines, ANSPs, airports, and regulators) and where concerns over
privacy, sovereignty, and commercial sensitivity prevent centralisation. By allowing stakeholders to contribute to
shared models without releasing their raw data, FedML provides a potential way of overcoming these barriers.
In defining the methodology, QUANTAIR focuses on the use of quantum computing as a conceptual analysis. The
project is scoped at TRL 1 not due to a lack of capability, but because current quantum hardware is not yet sufficiently
mature to enable higher -TRL validation in ATM. QUANTAIR therefore focuses on conceptual feasibility, while
identifying the pathways that can be pursued once the technology advances. The research examines how federated
learning frameworks in ATM could, in principle, benefit from quan tum methods once they become more capable,
particularly in handling large-scale optimisation and high-dimensional learning tasks. This ensures that the project
remains grounded in what is achievable at TRL 1, while still establishing a forward-looking research pathway that is
relevant to SESARs long-term ambitions.
In QUANTAIR, QFL is defined as the use of federated learning to enable distributed model training across ATM
stakeholders, combined with an explicit recognition of the potential role of quantum methods in overcoming
computational bottlenecks in the future. The research is not intended to deliver operational tools but to establish
=== PAGE 38 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 5 of 50
whether this approach is feasible and useful in an ATM context.
The methodology is based on several assumptions. It assumes that relevant data is distributed across multiple
stakeholders, that this data varies in quality and format, and that privacy and sovereignty concerns will prevent full
centralisation. It assumes that local training and global aggregation can be adapted to ATM use cases, and that
scalability may eventually require quantum-enabled methods. These assumptions frame the scope of the work and
define the limits of the feasibility analysis.
This conceptual basis is well suited to the projects objectives. The aim is not to deliver prototypes but to investigate
feasibility, develop high-level frameworks, identify potential benefits and limitations, and define pathways towards
higher-TRL research. FedML provides the structure for exploring distributed collaboration in ATM, and quantum
computing offers a forward-looking perspective that connects the work to the long-term vision of SESAR.
Exploratory Case 1: PREDICT (Privacy-Respecting Enhanced Departure Integration with Coordinated
Timing)
One of the four exploratory cases is PREDICT, which examines the problem of departure predictability and slot
allocation. In the current ATM system, uncertainty in the timing of departures is a persistent source of inefficiency.
Airlines, airports, and the Network Manager rely on estimates for the various trigger points within the flight, which
are used to consider airspace loading and whether regulation needs to be applied to protect the airspace. This includes
estimates used within A -CDM, such as Target Off -Blocks Time (TOBT), Target Start Approval Time (TSAT),
Estimated Take-Off Time (ETOT) etc., which are used to plan the allocation of slots via Calculated Take-Off Time
(CTOT) and to coordinate traffic flows, but these estimates are often unreliable and have a tolerance window applied.
Delays caused by late boarding, pushback, or ground handling propagate through th e system, leading to inefficient
use of airport capacity and sub -optimal flow management decisions. Improving departure predictability has been a
=== PAGE 39 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 6 of 50
long-standing goal in SESAR, but progress has been constrained by the limitations of centralised modelling
approaches.
The challenge is that the information required to predict departures accurately is distributed across multiple actors.
Airlines hold data on crew, passengers, and turnaround processes. Airports manage gate availability, ground
handling, and sequencing. Air navigation service providers track surface movements and manage departure
clearances. The network manager needs a system-wide picture in order to coordinate slots at a regional level. At
present, much of this information is kept within individual organisations, either because it is operationally sensitive
or because there are no mechanisms to share it in real time. As a result, centralised models rely on incomplete data,
and their predictions lack the accuracy needed to deliver significant improvements.
The PREDICT case investigates whether FedML could provide a more effective framework. In a federated approach,
each stakeholder would train a local model on its own data, and only model parameters would be shared. A global
model could then be constructed t hat reflects the behaviour of the entire system without requiring the exchange of
raw data. For example, an airlines local model could capture patterns in boarding times, while another airports
model could capture ground handling delays. The aggregated m odel could then produce more reliable A -CDM
estimates, which in turn could improve slot allocation and flow management decisions.
At TRL 1, the project does not attempt to build such models but rather to examine their conceptual feasibility. The
methodology involves defining a high -level framework for how federated models might be constructed in this
context, identifying what types of data would be needed at each node, and analysing the assumptions required for the
models to function. Indicators such as potential improvements in model fidelity, the robustness of aggregation across
heterogeneous datasets, and the scalability of the app roach will be considered. The analysis will also examine the
limitations of FedML in this application, such as the risk of bias if data quality differs significantly between
stakeholders or the difficulty of validating models in a safety-critical environment.
The role of quantum computing is considered solely as a conceptual pathway for future TRLs. With more accurate
ETOT predictions produced by federated models, the subsequent task of sequencing departure slots becomes a
highdimensional, NPhard scheduling problem in which classical methods are known to struggle.
Here, the federated setup is essential: only by combining distributed insights from airlines, airports, and network
managers can a sufficiently rich optimisation space be created for downstream quantummachinelearning algorithms
to act upon. The project w ill evaluate how quantum techniques, particularly hybrid quantumclassical approaches
such as the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA), variational quantum circuits, and
quantumannealingbased methods, could be applied at this global level. F or example, quantummachinelearning
models, seeded with federatedlearningderived estimates, could generate highquality slot sequences that minimise
delay propagation.
Furthermore, we will investigate whether quantum computers can effectively evaluate the probability of rare but
critical events, such as sector congestion, enabling unsafe or inefficient allocations to be rejected without exhaustive
simulation. Hybrid workflows will be designed so that classical preprocessing (e.g., feature extraction, constraint
filtering) feeds into the quantum optimiser, while classical postprocessing (e.g., solution refinement, robustness
checks) cleans and validates the quantum output.
These techniques illustrate how federated learning provides the conceptual foundation for future quantum integration,
while hybrid quantumclassical methods offer a practical bridge between current capabilities and the eventual
deployment of fully quantumenhanced scheduling solutions.
The expected output of the PREDICT case is therefore twofold: first, a conceptual framework showing how federated
learning can provide a privacy-preserving yet system-wide approach to departure predictability and slot allocation;
and second, a roadmap outlining how quantum machine learning could build on this federated foundation in future
TRL 23 work. By emphasising that accurate, system-wide models can only emerge in a federated setting, the case
highlights that quantum methods are not an alternative to data sharing but a complement that relies on federated
=== PAGE 40 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 7 of 50
inputs to be effective. This dual perspective will clarify both the feasibility and the limitations of QFL, and determine
whether distributed learning combined with quantum acceleration offers a credible path toward improved A -CDM
accuracy, operational efficiency, and capacity management.
Exploratory Case 2: HORIQON (High-altitude Operations with Real-time Integrated Quantum-Optimised
Navigation)
HORIQON addresses trajectory planning and integration in higher airspace. New entrants such as high -altitude
platforms, sub-orbital vehicles, supersonic and hypersonic aircraft, space transport systems, and certain military
operations create demands that d iffer significantly from conventional traffic. These vehicles operate with unique
performance profiles, often cross through controlled airspace at high speed, and interact with en-route flows at non-
standard altitudes. Current trajectory planning methods a re not well adapted to these conditions, and the lack of
operational data makes it difficult to develop predictive models. HORIQON investigates whether QFL could provide
a framework for sharing knowledge across stakeholders, enabling collaborative modellin g of higher -airspace and
high-speed trajectories while protecting sensitive operational and security-related data.
The main difficulty is that responsibility for higher airspace operations is spread across multiple organisations. All
stakeholders hold sensitive operational data, individual states maintain oversight of safety and sovereignty, and
ANSPs must manage interactions with conventional traffic within current controlled airspace. Sharing of information
is complex due to national security considerations, the commercial confidentiality of operational profiles, and
financial sensitivities. As a result, efforts to model higher airspace trajectories are often fragmented, and the lack of
integrated predictive capability makes it difficult to anticipate how such operations will affect the wider network.
The HORIQON case examines whether QFL could provide a way of combining insights from distributed datasets
without requiring disclosure of sensitive information. A federated model could allow the various stakeholders to train
local models on their own data while contributing to a global model that captures trajectory behaviours in higher
airspace. For example, space operators could train models on ascent and descent profiles, while ANSPs could
contribute models on interactions with controlled airspace. Aggre gating these models could improve the ability to
predict trajectories and their impact on the network, without requiring operators to reveal sensitive operational details.
At TRL 1, the focus is on developing a conceptual framework for how such federated models might be constructed
and on identifying the assumptions needed for them to function. The feasibility analysis will consider factors such as
the extreme heterogeneity of data sources, the sparsity of available datasets, and the sensitivity of mission
information. Indicators of feasibility will include the ability of federated models to generalise from limited local data,
the robustness of aggregation when nodes have ver y different information, and the potential scalability of the
approach.
The role of quantum computing is considered solely as a conceptual pathway for future TRLs. High -altitude 4D
trajectory deconfliction requires balancing safety, mission objectives, restricted zones, and sovereignty constraints
across multiple flight inform ation regions. This rapidly becomes a computationally hard problem, where classical
methods are unlikely to scale. A federated setup is indispensable since no single operator or authority can or will
provide the data diversity required to model high-altitude trajectories; only by linking their local models can a realistic
system-wide view emerge. On this federated foundation, quantum methods could potentially be applied in future
TRLs.
We will analyse if quantum machine learning algorithms and hybrid approaches are able to provide scalable ansatzes
to explore the large space of possible solutions, thus converging more rapidly to high -quality, conflict-free routes
than classical only approaches may allow. Quantum enhanced algorithms could evaluate rare-event probabilities such
as high-altitude conflict likelihood or space-weather-induced route degradation, leveraging distributed risk models
trained by operators. Quantum kernel methods are able to classify trajectory feasibility under multiple constraints,
refining the features provided.
=== PAGE 41 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 8 of 50
While quantum computing offers significant benefits for high -altitude 4D trajectory deconfliction, it is essential to
consider the potential obstacles that may arise during implementation, such as hardware limitations, regulatory
obstacles, and difficultie s in integrating quantum algorithms with existing classical systems. Addressing these
concerns will help ensure that the proposed solution is feasible and effective in practice.
The project will analyse the basic application principles of appropriate hybrid quantum algorithms in ATM according
to TRL 1.
Higher airspace, generally above flight level 550, is at present largely unused by commercial aviation. This relative
vacancy offers a rare opportunity to introduce new technologies and working methods without the immediate
constraints of dense traffic. By treating this environment as a testing ground, ATM can explore innovative approaches
to integration, coordination, and trajectory management more rapidly than in lower airspace, where changes are
slowed by operational complexity and legacy systems.
The expected output of the HORIQON case is therefore twofold: first, a conceptual framework for using federated
learning to support collaborative trajectory modelling in higher airspace; and second, a roadmap identifying where
quantum machine learning, and classification techniques could naturally extend this framework in later TRLs. By
making the federated approach explicit as the necessary foundation, the case highlights that quantum computing is
not a substitute for collaboration, but a complement that depends on federated inputs to be effective.
Exploratory Case 3: SHIELD (Strengthened Handling of Irregular Events and Landing Diversions)
SHIELD addresses the challenge of diversion capacity and network resilience. Air traffic management must be able
to cope with unexpected events such as severe weather, technical failures, medical emergencies, or security incidents.
When diversions occur, the availability of suitable airports and the capacity of surrounding airspace become critical
factors. At present, diversion planning is often managed locally, with each airline or ANSP focusing on its own area
of responsibility. The wider network view is limited, and information on diversion capacity is not always shared
across stakeholders. This leads to situations where capacity is underused in some areas while others face excessive
pressure, reducing the resilience of the system as a whole.
A key difficulty is that the data required to build a comprehensive picture of diversion capacity is distributed and
often sensitive. Airlines hold data on operational priorities and alternate airport preferences. Airports manage runway
and parking availab ility, ground handling resources, and emergency procedures. ANSPs control the surrounding
airspace and determine how many diversions can be safely accommodated. The Network Manager is responsible for
regional coordination but does not always have access to timely or detailed information from all stakeholders. At a
broader level, the European Aviation Crisis Coordination Cell (EACCC) is tasked with coordinating responses to
major disruptions, but its effectiveness depends on the availability of accurate and up-to-date information from across
the network. This fragmentation makes it difficult to anticipate the network-wide impact of diversions or to allocate
resources effectively during disruptions.
The SHIELD case explores whether federated learning could support more effective modelling of diversion capacity.
In this approach, each stakeholder would train a local model on its own data, capturing patterns such as airport
throughput under different we ather conditions or airline diversion preferences. These models could then be
aggregated to create a broader picture of diversion capacity at the network level, without requiring any actor to release
its raw operational data. Such a framework could improve situational awareness and decision -making during
disruptive events, helping the system to absorb shocks more effectively.
At TRL 1, the work does not involve implementing such models but rather examining their feasibility. The analysis
will define a conceptual framework showing how QFL might be applied to diversion capacity modelling. It will
consider assumptions such as the availability of local data, the variability of conditions across airports, and the need
for near-real-time aggregation during an unfolding disruption. Feasibility will be assessed using indicators such as
whether federated approaches can capture the divers ity of conditions across the network, how robust aggregated
models would be to incomplete or delayed inputs, and what kinds of benefits might arise in terms of resilience.
=== PAGE 42 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 9 of 50
The role of quantum computing is considered solely as a conceptual pathway for future TRLs. Diversion planning
requires balancing multiple constraints (such as fuel states, alternate readiness, sector loads, and weather) while
ensuring safety and minimising delay. This quickly becomes a largescale combinatorial optimisation problem,
especially during cascading disruptions where time pressure is critical. For diversion capacity, federation is crucial:
airlines, airports, ANSPs, and the Network Manager each control different pieces of the puzzle, and only their
combined local models can reveal the networks true resilience during disruptions.
On this federated foundation, quantum techniques could potentially be applied in future TRLs. Kernelbased quantum
anomaly detection could identify unusual diversion patterns from historical disruptions, enabling early recognition
of bottlenecks in evolving crises. Quantum random walks could explore the connectivity graph of airports and sectors,
rapidly highlighting underused alternates and feasible redirection chains. Quantum algorithms for probability
estimation could assess the likelihood of alternate ov erload or excessive airborne holding for candidate diversion
plans, improving safety assessments without the need for extensive classical Monte Carlo runs.
Hybrid quantumclassical methods (such as variational quantum circuits), the Quantum Approximate Optimization
Algorithm (QAOA), and quantumannealing based solvers will be evaluated for the diversion allocation problem
itself. These algorithms can encode the allocation task, producing high -quality allocations that minimise overload
and delay even with lastminute changes, while classical pre and postprocessing handles data preparation and result
validation.
The project will analyse the basic application principles of appropriate hybrid quantum algorithms in ATM according
to TRL 1.
The expected output of the SHIELD case is a feasibility assessment of federated learning for diversion capacity
modelling, coupled with a forward -looking roadmap showing how quantum optimisation, anomaly detection, and
probability estimation could reinforce network resilience under disruption. By making the federated approach explicit
as the foundation, the case highlights that quantum computing is not an alternative to collaboration but a complement
that depends on federated inputs. In doing so, SHIELD wil l clarify whether distributed approaches can improve
visibility and coordination during crises, supporting the long-term goal of a more resilient and robust European ATM
system.
Exploratory Case 4: CONTRADE (Climate-Optimised Navigation for TRAjectory DEsign)
CONTRADE investigates contrail prediction to support environmentally optimised planning. Persistent contrails and
the cirrus clouds they can form are recognised as a significant contributor to the climate impact of aviation. Avoiding
contrail-forming regions can therefore reduce the environmental footprint of flights, but predicting where contrails
will occur is technically challenging. Accurate prediction maps require the integration of meteorological data,
complex atmospheric conditions, aircraft performance characteristics, and traffic patterns. At present, this integration
is limited, and decision-making relies on simplified models that cannot capture the full variability of the prevailing
atmospheric conditions.
The challenge lies in the distributed nature of the relevant data. Meteorological agencies produce forecasts of
temperature, humidity, and wind fields at multiple altitudes. Airlines hold data on aircraft performance and
operational routing preferences, in cluding cost-index settings that determine whether the airline prioritises speed,
fuel efficiency, or other operational factors. This information is highly sensitive, as it reflects commercial strategies
and fuel-burn targets. ANSPs manage the airspace structure and flow constraints that determine whether avoidance
trajectories are feasible. In addition, contrail mitigation itself involves a complex trade-off: avoiding contrail-forming
regions may require flying at less efficient altitudes, leading to highe r fuel burn and associated harmful emissions.
Each actor therefore possesses part of the information needed, but there is no mechanism for combining it into shared
contrail-risk maps without significant data exchange. Concerns over intellectual property, operational sensitivity, and
the lack of common standards further hinder centralised approaches.
=== PAGE 43 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 10 of 50
The CONTRADE case investigates whether federated learning could provide a framework for collaborative contrail-
risk modelling. In this approach, each stakeholder would train local models that capture how their data contributes to
contrail formation. Meteorological agencies could model atmospheric conditions, while aircraft manufacturers could
contribute data on performance characteristics and contrail sensitivity of specific airframes and engines. Airlines
would provide models based on their operational use of these aircraft, including cost-index preferences that determine
whether flights are optimised for speed, fuel efficiency, or specific fuel-burn targets. ANSPs could contribute models
that reflect operational feasibility in terms of sector capacity and airspace restrictions. Aggregating these models
could produce risk maps that are richer and more accurate than those generated by any single actor, without requiring
raw data to be shared.
At TRL 1, the work is limited to conceptual analysis. The methodology involves defining the types of local models
that might be trained, the assumptions needed for aggregation, and the indicators that could be used to judge
feasibility. These indicators in clude the potential improvement in the resolution and reliability of risk maps, the
robustness of results when datasets are incomplete or inconsistent, and the scalability of the approach to larger
geographic regions. The analysis will also consider limitations, such as the challenge of validating contrail predictions
against observed outcomes and the computational demands of processing large volumes of atmospheric data.
The role of quantum computing is considered a potential future enabler. Contrail avoidance routing is inherently a
multi-objective optimisation problem: flights must minimise climate forcing, fuel burn, and congestion
simultaneously. Classical methods struggle as the number of route/altitude combinations grows.
Here, the federated setup is essential: only by combining local models from meteorological agencies, aircraft
manufacturers, airlines, and ANSPs can the diverse data needed for contrail prediction be assembled without
compromising sensitive inputs.
On this federated foundation, quantum methods could extend capability. Hybrid quantumclassical optimisation (such
as variational quantum circuits or the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA)) could evaluate many
potential route altitude combina tions more efficiently, enabling targeted contrail avoidance without degrading
overall network performance. Quantum algorithms for probability estimation could assess the chance of contrail
persistence along candidate routes using aggregated weather performance models, reducing the need for largescale
classical sampling. Finally, quantum kernels could project aggregated weather performance data into high -
dimensional feature spaces where persistent contrail conditions become linearly separable, improving the precision
of contrail riskmaps.
The expected outcome of the CONTRADE case is to demonstrate whether federated learning can provide a practical
basis for collaborative contrail -risk mapping, and to highlight where quantum methods could eventually enhance
such models. Rather than positioning quantum as a separate solution, the analysis will explore how machine learning,
estimation, and classification techniques can be layered on top of federated inputs to deliver more accurate and
actionable risk maps. By extending QFL into the environmenta l domain, CONTRADE broadens the projects
relevance: alongside efficiency, integration, and resilience, it directly supports SESARs strategic objective of
reducing aviations climate impact and making Europe the most environmentally sustainable region to fly.
A Coordinated approach
Taken together, the four exploratory cases ensure that the methodology is comprehensive and representative of the
challenges facing European ATM. PREDICT addresses operational efficiency in day -to-day traffic management,
HORIQON looks ahead to the integration of new entrants in higher airspace, SHIELD focuses on network resilience
under disruption, and CONTRADE examines environmental sustainability. By covering efficiency, integration,
resilience, and environment, the project avoids concentrating on a single niche problem and instead demonstrates
how Quantum Federated Learning could, in principle, be applied across the full scope of the European ATM Master
Plan. This breadth ensures that the feasibility analysis is robust, highlights both common and domain -specific
challenges, and maximises the value of the results for guiding future SESAR research.
=== PAGE 44 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 11 of 50
Transversal cross-cutting
The four exploratory cases provide the primary structure for the research, but several cross -cutting considerations
influence the methodology as a whole. These reflect the interdisciplinary nature of the work, the constraints under
which the research must operate, and the principles that ensure it is consistent with European policy goals.
The project requires expertise from multiple domains. Air traffic management provides the operational context,
defining the problems that need to be addressed and the performance criteria against which solutions must be judged.
Machine learning contributes the methods for distributed model training, while quantum research provides the longer-
term perspective on scalability and algorithmic possibilities. Regulatory and policy insight ensures that the proposed
frameworks remain realistic in the institutional environment of European aviation. The combination of these
perspectives is essential; no single discipline is capable of addressing the research questions in isolation. The
methodology is therefore deliberately interdisciplinary, ensuring that technical fe asibility is always considered in
relation to operational relevance and policy constraints.
The assumptions underpinning the methodology are also common across the exploratory cases. These include the
expectation that operational data will remain fragmented across multiple stakeholders, that privacy and sovereignty
concerns will prevent full centralisation, and that datasets will be heterogeneous in both quality and structure. The
feasibility analyses therefore focus on whether federated learning can function under these conditions rather than
assuming idealised data availability. A further assumption is that validation of distributed models in a safety-critical
domain will pose challenges that cannot be fully resolved at TRL 1. Instead, the project aims to identify those
challenges explicitly, providing a roadmap for how they could be addressed in higher-TRL work.
The research is conducted in accordance with the “do no significant harm” principle of the EU Taxonomy Regulation.
The work involves only conceptual frameworks and analyses, and does not generate environmental impacts directly.
Its contribution is instead positive, particularly in the CONTRADE case, where the methodology is explicitly directed
towards reducing the climate impact of aviation by enabling contrail avoidance strategies. The project also contributes
indirectly to sustainability by exploring meth ods that may improve efficiency and resilience, thereby reducing
unnecessary fuel burn.
Because the project involves the application of machine learning concepts, attention is given to the robustness and
explainability of such methods. Federated learning introduces specific risks, including the potential for bias if local
datasets are unbalanced and the difficulty of validating aggregated models when raw data is not accessible. These
issues will be examined systematically in the feasibility analyses, and potential safeguards will be identified. The
project anticipates that any future integration of quantum methods will require similar attention to transparency and
verification, particularly in a safety-critical environment. The project therefore aligns with European principles on
trustworthy AI by ensuring that robustness, reproducibility, and explainability are considered from the outset, even
at TRL 1.
In summary, the methodology integrates expertise from multiple disciplines, is grounded in explicit assumptions
about the ATM environment, complies with European sustainability principles, and recognises the importance of
robustness and explainability in AI methods. These cross-cutting considerations ensure that the exploratory analyses
are not only technically sound but also aligned with the broader requirements of the aviation system and the European
research framework.
Open Scientific Principles and Responsible Research
The methodology also incorporates principles of open science and responsible research management. Although the
project is exploratory and limited to TRL 1, the outputs include conceptual frameworks, feasibility assessments, and
analytical results that can be openly shared. Publications will be made available in open -access journals or
repositories in line with Horizon Europe requirements. Preprints and working papers will be released where
appropriate to support early dissemination and peer feedback. Models and analytical frameworks developed during
=== PAGE 45 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 12 of 50
the project will be documented and, where possible, shared in a way that enables scrutiny and reuse by the wider
research community.
Research data management follows the FAIR principles (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable). The project
will not generate new operational datasets from its activities. Instead, it will make use of modest datasets that may
include synthetic data c reated for illustrative purposes, publicly available sources such as EUROCONTROL
performance statistics or open meteorological data, and structured documentation of modelling assumptions. These
materials will be curated with clear documentation of provenance, scope, and format. A data management plan will
be produced by month six of the project and updated as required. Persistent identifiers will be used to ensure
findability, and trusted repositories will be selected for long -term preservation. Access will be granted in line with
open-access requirements, while any data subject t o restrictions for confidentiality or security will be documented
with clear justification. Reusability will be supported by applying open licences where appropriate and by providing
explanatory documentation of models and algorithms.
The project recognises that the integration of a gender dimension in research content is mandatory under Horizon
Europe unless clearly irrelevant. In the case of QUANTAIR, the subject matter involves the conceptual exploration
of federated learning and qua ntum computing in ATM. The scientific and operational questions addressed are not
influenced by biological sex or social gender factors, and the research outputs do not have a differentiated impact
along those lines. For this reason, the gender dimension is not directly relevant to the research content. However, the
project will ensure that dissemination and communication activities are inclusive, using language and imagery that
reflect diversity, and ensuring that engagement with stakeholders and end users is representative of the community.
These measures ensure that QUANTAIR is aligned with the principles of open and responsible science. The outputs
will be accessible to the wider research community, the data will be managed transparently, and inclusivity will be
ensured in dissemination and communication. Even at TRL 1, these practices increase the value of the research by
making it reproducible, transparent, and usable as a foundation for future SESAR work.
Leveraging National and International R&I Activities
The proposed research builds directly upon major European R&I activities and SESAR strategic priorities, ensuring
continuity and maximising return on investment from prior programmes. One important foundation is AI-CHAIN
(EUROCONTROL, 20222024), which validated the use of collaborative machine learning on distributed, privacy-
sensitive ATM datasets, including Estimated Take-Off Times (ETOT) and trajectory prediction. AI-CHAIN
showed that federated models could deliver improved accuracy without requiring raw data sharing. QUANTAIR
will extend these results by exploring Quantum Federated Learning (QFL) as a means to address the scalability and
machine learning challenges identified in AI-CHAIN. This will be achieved by reusing AI-CHAIN benchmarks,
adapting its federated architectures, and maintaining close contact with EUROCONTROL stakeholders to
guarantee methodological alignment.
The SESAR Master Plan 2025 provides further direction. It explicitly recognises that “machine learning is used in
combination with conventional deterministic algorithms for trajectory prediction, ATFM and ATC conflict
detection” and calls for the development of AI capabilities enabling the next generation of ATM platforms. It also
underlines the importance of “virtualisation and cyber-secure data sharing” and identifies “AI for aviation” as an
industrial research priority. Furthermore, the Master Plan stresses the need for ATM modernisation to shift towards
“a modern, data-driven and cloud-based service-oriented architecture,” facilitating privacy-preserving and
interoperable collaboration across stakeholders. QUANTAIR responds to these calls by investigating QFL as a
privacy-preserving AI mechanism to overcome sovereignty and sensitivity barriers that prevent centralised data
sharing, aligning its exploratory cases (departure predictability, higher airspace integration, diversion capacity, and
contrail avoidance) with SESAR Strategic Deployment Objectives, notably SDO 3 on Dynamic Airspace
Configuration, SDO 5 on the Transformation to Trajectory-Based Operations (TBO), and SDO 8 on Service-
Oriented Delivery Models. In doing so, the project contributes to SESARs long-term roll-out objectives, directly
addressing the shift towards SDO 5 for precise 4D trajectory optimisation, enabling resilience and scalability in line
with SDO 3, and supporting the transition to SDO 8. It also adds value to SESARs automation and AI research
=== PAGE 46 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 13 of 50
stream, particularly in the areas of high-dimensional optimisation, safety-critical validation, and cross-stakeholder
model aggregation.
Beyond SESAR, QUANTAIR will connect to the broader European and international R&I ecosystem. It will
ensure consistency with Digital Sky Demonstrators, align its environmental work on contrail avoidance and
climate-optimised trajectories with the Clean Aviation and Zero-Emission Aircraft programmes, and take into
account international initiatives such as ICAO, FAA NextGen, and NASA ATM-X to ensure interoperability and
standardisation.
To embed its results in the SESAR ecosystem, QUANTAIR will feed its conceptual frameworks and feasibility
analyses into SESAR repositories and knowledge-sharing channels, organise technical workshops with AI-CHAIN
and SESAR 3 JU expert groups to align assumptions and validation methods, and publish results in open-access
venues while maintaining strong links with SESAR Innovation Days and technical consultation fora. In this way,
the project will not duplicate previous work but rather extend and complement SESARs federated learning
strategy, anchoring its results in the Master Plan 2025 vision of a Digital European Sky enabled by AI, privacy-
preserving data sharing, and service-oriented architectures.
Interdisciplinary Integration of Expertise
The consortium combines three complementary disciplines essential to the project: quantum algorithms, distributed
orchestration, and operational ATM. DLR QSOC contributes expertise in quantum computing, quantum machine
learning and optimisation, leading the scientific feasibility assessment of applying quantum methods to federated
learning. Qoro Quantum brings knowledge of distributed systems and orchestration, ensuring that the frameworks
are technically realistic, privacy-preserving, and aligned with SESARs transition to service-oriented architectures.
SkyNav International adds operational ATM and navigation expertise, embedding safety, regulatory, and
interoperability requirements into the exploratory cases so that the results reflect real-world constraints and
stakeholder needs.
Integration will be achieved through co-design workshops, joint development of conceptual frameworks, and
systematic cross-review of results. DLR will validate the scientific soundness of the approaches, Qoro will ensure
architectural robustness and scalability, and SkyNav will test operational relevance against SESARs Strategic
Deployment Objectives. This structure ensures that the project outputs are not isolated academic exercises but
practical and credible contributions to SESARs research pipeline, providing actionable pathways for future work
on Quantum Federated Learning in ATM.
The combined skill set is both unique and directly relevant to the projects aims. Quantum algorithm research alone
cannot address operational feasibility; distributed orchestration expertise alone cannot resolve ATM privacy and
sovereignty barriers; and operational ATM expertise alone cannot scale to emerging computational methods. By
uniting these three perspectives, the consortium can evaluate Quantum Federated Learning in a way no single
partner could achieve in isolation. This integration ensures that the project bridges the gap between theoretical
research, technical system design, and operational ATM practice, delivering results that are both innovative and
usable within the SESAR framework.
Role of Social Sciences and Humanities (SSH)
The proposed work does not directly require integration of Social Sciences and Humanities (SSH) disciplines, as
the focus is on the conceptual feasibility of Quantum Federated Learning for Air Traffic Management at TRL 1.
The research is primarily technical, combining quantum algorithmics, distributed computing architectures, and
operational ATM knowledge. Its outputs will be high-level frameworks, feasibility analyses, and pathways for
future research rather than social or behavioural studies.
That said, the consortium recognises that ATM modernisation is a socio-technical transformation. The SESAR
Master Plan 2025 explicitly highlights the evolving role of human operators in humanmachine teaming and the
=== PAGE 47 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 14 of 50
need for trustworthy AI-based systems to ensure adoption in safety-critical contexts. These aspects fall outside the
TRL 1 scope of QUANTAIR but are highly relevant to subsequent SESAR research. The project will therefore
remain attentive to SSH findings from related SESAR activities on data governance, humanmachine trust, and
stakeholder acceptance, and ensure that its conceptual frameworks are compatible with future interdisciplinary
studies. In this way, while SSH integration is not required for the current exploratory work, the project establishes a
technical foundation that can be enriched by SSH contributions in later phases.
Research Data Management and Research Outputs
QUANTAIR is scoped at TRL 1 and will not generate large operational datasets. The main outputs will be
conceptual frameworks, feasibility analyses, modelling artefacts, and small synthetic datasets used to test federated
learning and quantum machine learning concepts. Outputs will be textual (reports, frameworks), numerical
(synthetic trajectory/weather data), and software-based (lightweight code templates), with total volume <10 GB.
Where public datasets (e.g. Eurocontrol performance reports, meteorological data) are combined with synthetic
data, provenance will be documented.
Findability. All outputs will be assigned persistent identifiers (DOIs) via trusted repositories. Metadata will follow
Horizon Europe requirements to ensure indexing and searchability.
Accessibility. Deliverables and publications will be open access. Software and modelling artefacts will be hosted on
GitHub. Sensitive information, if any, will be restricted but metadata will remain visible for verification.
Importantly, in line with the federated learning approach, only trained model weights and parameters will be
shared, never raw stakeholder data.
Interoperability. Data and code will be provided in non-proprietary formats (CSV, JSON, Python notebooks).
Metadata will use recognised standards (e.g. Dublin Core) and SESAR taxonomies to ensure compatibility with
other ATM projects.
Reusability. Outputs will carry open licenses (CC-BY for documents, Apache 2.0 or MIT for code) to enable reuse
and integration into future SESAR projects. Documentation and environment files will accompany software to
support reproducibility.
Curation and Storage. DLR will curate scientific data and models, Qoro will maintain software repositories, and
SkyNav will validate operational relevance. Outputs will be preserved in institutional repositories for at least ten
years. A Data Management Plan will be delivered by Month 6 and updated before project close.
This approach ensures compliance with FAIR principles and makes results directly reusable by the SESAR
community in follow-on TRL 23 activities.
#§CON-MET-CM§# #§COM-PLE-CP§# #§REL-EVA-RE§#
2. Impact #@IMP-ACT-IA@#
2.1 Projects pathways towards impact
The results of QUANTAIR are expected to make a meaningful contribution to the SESAR programmes medium -
term outcomes and to the wider long -term impacts described in the Work Programme. The project is positioned at
TRL 1, and its immediate outputs are conceptual frameworks and feasibility assessments. The impact therefore lies
not in the delivery of deployable systems, but in shaping the research agenda by establishing whether Quantum
Federated Learning (QFL) provides a credible new approach for ATM. By clarifying the potential scope, identifying
=== PAGE 48 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 15 of 50
enabling conditions, and defining pathways to higher-TRL research, the project provides the knowledge base required
for Europe to maintain leadership in this field, both in federated approaches to ATM and in the application of
emerging quantum methods for large-scale optimisation and risk assessment.
The pathways to impact extend across four domains that correspond to the projects exploratory cases. Each case
addresses a distinct challenge within the ATM Master Plan, ensuring that the projects contribution is broad and
relevant.
The PREDICT case supports efficiency and capacity by addressing the challenge of departure predictability and slot
allocation. Delays at departure propagate through the network, and current models are limited because the relevant
information is fragmented across stakeholders. By investigating whether QFL could enable collaborative prediction
without compromising data privacy, the project contributes to the SESAR objective of improving predictability as a
foundation for advanced demandcapacity balancing. Even at TRL 1, the project identifies how federated approaches
might reduce uncertainty in departure planning and sets out pathways for higher-TRL research that could ultimately
improve the efficiency of European airspace.
The HORIQON case supports the safe integration of new entrants in higher airspace. The growing presence of high-
altitude platforms, sub -orbital flights, super - and hyper-sonic vehicles, and space transport operations introduces
uncertainty into ATM, and the lack of shared data across stakeholders makes it difficult to model these trajectories.
QUANTAIR explores whether QFL could provide a framework for collaborative trajectory modelling under strict
confidentiality constraints. This aligns with SESARs objective of ensuring the seamless integration of all airspace
users and supports the EASA Higher Airspace Operations roadmap. It also complements ICAOs ongoing work in
the ATMOPS Panel, ATMRPP, and ICAO Paris, where the need for new coordination mechanisms for high-altitude
operations has been identified. The projects outputs provide a research basis that can inform both European and
global efforts in this domain.
The SHIELD case contributes to resilience and contingency management by addressing diversion handling and rapid
network reorganisation. Current approaches are fragmented, with limited visibility of network-wide capacity during
disruptions. By examining whe ther QFL could enable distributed modelling of diversion capacity, the project
explores how resilience could be enhanced without requiring stakeholders to share sensitive operational data. This
directly supports SESARs long-term ambition of building a more resilient Digital European Sky. It also aligns with
ICAOs GATMOC, which emphasises the need for globally harmonised contingency procedures and collaborative
decision-making. By identifying how distributed modelling could underpin these objectives, QUANT AIR
contributes to the policy and research foundations required to manage disruptions more effectively at both regional
and global levels.
The CONTRADE case contributes to environmental sustainability by considering contrail prediction mapping.
Persistent contrails represent one of aviations most significant climate impacts, but predicting them requires
combining data from meteorological agencies, airlines, and ANSPs. QUANTAIR explores whether QFL could be
used to generate richer and more reliable contrail prediction maps without requiring raw data exchange. This supports
SESARs environmental pillar, directly addresses the Horizon Europe priority of making Europe the most
environmentally friendly region to fly, and complements wider European climate objectives. It also aligns with
ICAOs sustainability agenda by exploring methods to reduce the non -CO₂ impacts of aviation. By identifying
pathways for integrating distributed contrail modelling into ATM processes, the project sets the stage for future
research that could enable environmentally optimised trajectory planning.
Across these domains, the project contributes to the realisation of the Digital European Sky vision. QFL represents
a novel way of enabling scalable services supported by a digital ecosystem, where distributed data sources can
contribute to shared models w ithout compromising sovereignty or security. This directly addresses one of the
structural challenges of the Digital European Sky: how to build a networked architecture that is both data -rich and
privacy-preserving. While QUANTAIR does not deliver technica l systems, it identifies how distributed and
potentially quantum -enabled approaches could contribute to this architecture in the longer term, by combining
federated models with quantum machine learning, estimation, and classification methods capable of han dling the
=== PAGE 49 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 16 of 50
scale and complexity of future ATM services.
The expected impacts also extend beyond SESAR. By addressing data-sharing challenges in ATM through QFL, the
project informs EASAs regulatory strategies for higher airspace, ICAOs work on contingency and environmental
management, and the global framework established by the GATMOC. It provides European stakeholders with early
insight into how quantum methods might eventually support large -scale, secure, and collaborative ATM services,
strengthening Europes position as a leader in both ATM modernisation and quantum research.
The scale and significance of these impacts must be interpreted in the context of TRL 1. The project does not produce
immediate operational benefits, but it does set the agenda for higher -TRL work that could. Its contribution lies in
providing the first st ructured assessment of QFL in ATM, across efficiency, new entrants, resilience, and
sustainability. By demonstrating that the concept is feasible in principle, QUANTAIR enables future SESAR projects
to pursue targeted TRL 2 3 developments with confidence. If successful, this pathway could, over the medium to
long term, support Europes ambition to deliver the most environmentally friendly, efficient, resilient, and digitally
integrated ATM system in the world.
The achievement of these impacts depends on several factors beyond the scope of the project. Progress in quantum
hardware and algorithms may be slower than anticipated, delaying the availability of scalable quantum methods.
Conversely, rapid advances could create opportunities earlier than expected, underlining the importance of SESAR
being prepared with conceptual frameworks and use cases that can be taken up as soon as technology allows.
Stakeholders may also be cautious about adopting federated approaches if they perceive the governance, validation,
or liability arrangements as unclear. Regulatory frameworks for higher airspace and environmental modelling may
evolve at different speeds across regions, creating asymmetries in adoption. These are not risks to the project itself,
but barriers that may influence whether the pathways identified can be realised in practice. By identifying them early,
QUANTAIR ensures that future SESAR and policy work can anticipate these challenges and address them
systematically.
2.2 Measures to maximise impact - Dissemination, exploitation and communication #@COM-DIS-VIS-CDV@#
The project adopts a proportionate but structured approach to dissemination, exploitation, and communication to
ensure that its results are visible, usable, and positioned to generate impact beyond the immediate project lifetime.
At TRL 1, the outputs are primarily conceptual frameworks, feasibility analyses, and structured assessments of
Quantum Federated Learning (QFL) in ATM. The plan therefore emphasises knowledge sharing, policy relevance,
and preparing pathways for follow-on research, rather than commercialisation.
Communication activities will be modest but continuous, designed to ensure visibility of the project and to inform a
wider audience about its purpose and benefits. The consortium will establish a project website as a primary
information point, complemented by short news items and updates on professional social media platforms. These
activities will highlight the relevance of quantum computing and federated learning to aviation in terms
understandable to non-specialists, showing how such research contributes to efficiency, resilience, sustainability, and
the safe integration of new entrants. Outreach will be proportionate to the scale of the project, relying on existing
channels within the consortium, which collectively offers a global and cross-disciplinary network of contacts across
research, industry, and regulatory communities.
Dissemination will focus on the scientific and technical community, particularly those engaged in ATM
modernisation and quantum computing research. Results will be published in open-access journals and presented at
conferences such as SESAR Innovation Days and relevant academic venues. Where appropriate, preprints will be
released to encourage early engagement and peer feedback. The project will also contribute to SESAR knowledge-
sharing channels and technical workshops to ensure that results feed directly into the wider programme.
Dissemination will be coordinated so that outputs are available in formats that are accessible and reusable, consistent
with open science practices.
=== PAGE 50 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 17 of 50
Exploitation will take place primarily through institutional and programme channels. The conceptual frameworks
and feasibility assessments generated by QUANTAIR are intended for direct uptake by future SESAR research at
TRL 23. They also provide material of interest to ATM stakeholders, who can use the findings to inform early
thinking on data -sharing models and the potential of federated approaches. Regulators such as EASA, and
international bodies such as ICAO, will also benefit from the insights generat ed, particularly in areas of higher
airspace operations, contingency management, and environmental sustainability. Although no commercial
exploitation is expected at TRL 1, the intellectual outputs represent a foundation that can be carried forward in
subsequent projects or policy initiatives. Intellectual property will be managed in line with Horizon Europe rules,
with ownership of results defined in the consortium agreement. Given the conceptual nature of the work, results will
primarily be disseminated openly, with protection measures applied only if necessary to safeguard future exploitation
potential.
Feedback to policy measures is an integral part of the plan. The projects outputs are directly relevant to ongoing
European and international discussions, including EASAs Higher Airspace Operations roadmap, ICAOs ATMOPS
and ATMRPP panels, and the global framework provided by the GATMOC. By sharing findings through technical
workshops, regulatory consultations, and programme -level interactions, QUANTAIR will provide evidence to
support policy development and help shape future research agendas.
This first version of the dissemination and exploitation plan provides a framework that is appropriate to the scope
and maturity of the project. A detailed plan will be produced as a mandatory deliverable within three months of
project start and updated as necessary during the project. Together, these measures will ensure that the outputs of
QUANTAIR are widely disseminated, appropriately exploited, and communicated effectively to the scientific
community, policymakers, stakeholders, and the public.
References
[1] Abbas, Amira, et al. "Challenges and opportunities in quantum optimization." Nature Reviews Physics (2024): 1-18.
[2] Li, Li, et al. "A review of applications in federated learning." Computers & Industrial Engineering 149 (2020): 106854.
[3] Ruiz, Sergio, et al. "Privacy-preserving federated machine learning in ATM: experimental results from two use cases."
Proceedings of the 12th SESAR Innovation days (2022).
[4] Ballester, Rocco, Jesus Cerquides, and Luis Artiles. "Quantum federated learning: a comprehensive literature review
of foundations, challenges, and future directions." Quantum Machine Intelligence 7.2 (2025): 1-29.
[5] SESAR Joint Undertaking, European ATM Master Plan 2025 Edition (2025).
#§COM-DIS-VIS-CDV§#
=== PAGE 51 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 18 of 50
2.3 Summary
KEY ELEMENT OF THE IMPACT SECTION
D & E & C MEASURES
What dissemination, exploitation and communication
measures will you apply to the results?
Results will be communicated through a dedicated
website, social media updates, and targeted news items
for non-specialist audiences. Dissemination to the
scientific community will use open-access journals,
preprints, and conferences (SESAR Innovation Days,
quantum/AI venues). Exploitation will occur through
SESAR follow-on projects, input to regulatory
roadmaps (EASA, ICAO), and alignment with
international R&I activities. All outputs will be openly
shared under FAIR principles, with repositories
ensuring transparency and reuse. A mid-project and
final dissemination event will engage stakeholders
directly.
EXPECTED RESULTS
What do you expect to generate by the end of the
project?
By the end of the project, QUANTAIR will deliver:
• Conceptual frameworks for applying QFL to
four representative ATM challenges
(departure predictability, higher -airspace
integration, diversion capacity, contrail
avoidance).
• Feasibility analyses identifying assumptions,
indicators, potential benefits, and limitations.
• Roadmaps defining steps towards TRL 2 3,
including conditions under which quantum
methods may provide added value.
• Open, reproducible outputs (reports, models,
synthetic datasets) supporting future SESAR
research.
SPECIFIC NEEDS
What are the specific needs that triggered this
project?
Air Traffic Management (ATM) faces structural
barriers to data sharing, scalability, and
resilience. Operational datasets are fragmented
across airlines, ANSPs, airports, and regulators,
making centralised modelling infeasible due to
sovereignty, confidentiality, and security
constraints. At the same time, growing system
complexity (multi-flight optimisation,
integration of higher-airspace entrants,
resilience to disruption, and contrail avoidance
pushes classical methods to their limits. Europe
requires a structured assessment of whether
Quantum Federated Learning (QFL) can provide
a privacy-preserving, scalable framework for
collaborative modelling that is aligned with
SESARs Digital European Sky ambitions.
=== PAGE 52 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 19 of 50
#§IMP-ACT-IA§#
TARGET GROUPS
Who will use or further up-take the results of the
project? Who will benefit from the results of the
project?
• SESAR research community and Joint
Undertaking programme teams.
• ATM operational stakeholders (airlines,
ANSPs, airports, Network Manager).
• Regulatory and policy bodies (EASA, ICAO
panels, European Commission).
• Academic and industrial researchers in
federated learning, quantum computing, and
AI for aviation.
• Wider environmental and climate policy
stakeholders interested in contrail mitigation
and sustainable aviation.
OUTCOMES
What change do you expect to see after
successful dissemination and
exploitation of project results to the
target group(s)?
The project will provide the first
structured evidence base for QFL in
ATM, enabling SESAR to judge
whether and how to pursue higher-
TRL development. Stakeholders will
gain conceptual frameworks that
inform data-sharing models,
integration of new entrants, resilience
strategies, and climate-optimised
navigation. Dissemination ensures that
results are embedded in SESAR
roadmaps, regulatory debates, and
international standardisation efforts.
IMPACTS
What are the expected wider scientific, economic and societal
effects of the project contributing to the expected impacts outlined
in the respective destination in the work programme?
Wider impacts include:
• Scientific: establishment of benchmarks and
methodologies for QFL across distributed, safety -critical
domains.
• Economic: foundations for more efficient, resilient, and
sustainable European ATM, reducing costs from delay,
disruption, and inefficient fuel burn.
• Societal: enhanced resilience of the air transport system,
reduced climate impact via contrail avoidance, and
strengthened European leadership in privacy-preserving AI
and quantum research.
In the longer term, QUANTAIR contributes directly to the
Work Programme objective of delivering the most
environmentally friendly, efficient, resilient, and digitally
integrated ATM system worldwide.
=== PAGE 53 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 20 of 50
3. Quality and efficiency of the implementation #@QUA-LIT-QL@# #@WRK-PLA-WP@#
3.1 Work plan and resources
The design of the QUANTAIR work plan reflects both the scope of a TRL 1 exploratory research project and the
need to provide clear evidence of progress at defined review points. The structure is kept deliberately lean, with four
work packages that separate management and outreach activities from the research, while ensuring that each of the
projects objectives is addressed in a coherent way. This approach avoids unnecessary fragmentation but still gives
full visibility to the mandatory elements of management, dissemination, exploitation, and data management.
GANTT-Chart overview including work packages, milestones and deliverables
The first work package covers project management and the cross-cutting activities on communication, dissemination,
and exploitation. This ensures that the day-to-day running of the project, financial and administrative tasks, reporting
to the SESAR JU, and quality assurance are all handled in one place. The same package also includes the production
and maintenance of the Project Management Plan, the Data Management Plan, and the Communication and
Dissemination Plan. These are not treated as box -ticking exercises but as tools to give the consortium a common
framework for how the work will be organised and how outputs will be shared with the wider research and
stakeholder community.
The research itself is divided into two phases. The first nine months (WP2) are dedicated to setting the foundations.
This includes scoping the four exploratory cases - PREDICT, HORIQON, SHIELD, and CONTRADE - agreeing the
assumptions and indicators that will be used to test feasibility, and producing the initial research plan and exploratory
report. This early phase is designed to provide tangible outputs that can be reviewed and challenged at the interim
stage, while still leaving scope for refinement. It allows the consortium to put forward initial concepts and
frameworks without claiming premature certainty, which is consistent with the TRL 1 nature of the project.
The second research phase (WP3) runs from month 10 to month 18 and builds directly on the initial results. Here the
consortium revisits the assumptions, tests them across the four cases, and develops the final research plan and report.
The emphasis in this phase is on refinement and integration: drawing out the lessons that are common across cases,
understanding where QFL may have genuine promise for ATM, and identifying the open questions that must be
addressed in future TRL 23 research. This structure gives the project a rhythm: first to establish and scope, then to
=== PAGE 54 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 21 of 50
refine and consolidate. By the end of month 18, the core research outputs are complete and ready for review.
The final work package (WP4) is dedicated to ensuring that the results are not only written down but also
communicated, preserved, and made available for exploitation. This includes the production of the final exploitation
and impact strategy, compliance with open science and repository requirements, and the organisation of a final event
to share the findings with both the research community and operational stakeholders. Dedicating a separate work
package to this task provides clarity and ensures that disse mination and exploitation are not left to the margins of
project management, but treated as substantive outputs in their own right.
The sequencing of activities is straightforward. WP2 provides the initial research outputs and ensures that the
consortium can demonstrate progress at the interim review. WP3 takes these results forward, deepening the analysis
and completing the research e ffort. WP4 then consolidates the outputs and ensures their visibility. WP1 runs
throughout, providing governance, coordination, and quality assurance. The interdependencies are limited but clear:
WP2 feeds WP3, WP3 feeds WP4, and WP1 underpins the whole process. This simplicity is deliberate, allowing the
consortium to concentrate on the substance of the research rather than the mechanics of coordination.
Overall, the work plan balances clarity with proportionality. The structure makes it possible to demonstrate progress
at the interim and final stages, while keeping the number of work packages aligned to the scale of a TRL 1 activity.
Most of the effort is concentrated in the two research phases, where the exploratory cases are scoped, analysed, and
refined. Management, communication, and exploitation activities run in parallel but remain light and focused,
ensuring that resources are directed primarily to the research. In this way, the plan ensures that the projects objectives
can be met within the available timeframe and that the results are prepared for further development in future SESAR
research.
3.2 Capacity of participants and consortium as a whole #@CON-SOR-CS@# #@PRJ-MGT-PM@#
The consortium for QUANTAIR is deliberately small and highly focused. It brings together three partners with
complementary expertise that together cover the full range of knowledge needed for exploratory research on Quantum
Federated Learning in Air Traffic Management. This structure avoids fragmentation while ensuring that the project
objectives are addressed from scientific, operational, and regulatory perspectives.
The disciplinary scope is broad. The project combines expertise in advanced computing and federated learning, in
ATM modelling and SESAR research methods, and in the operational and regulatory environment of European
aviation. This inter-disciplinary mix is central to the projects feasibility. Quantum computing and federated learning
alone cannot be meaningfully assessed without ATM expertise to define realistic use cases and indicators, and ATM
modelling by itself cannot explore the potential of novel com putational paradigms. By combining the three, the
project ensures that technical exploration remains grounded in operational reality, while operational questions are
informed by the latest research in computing and data science.
Each partner contributes distinct capabilities. One partner provides established experience in ATM research and
modelling, including the frameworks and methods that underpin SESAR exploratory research. A second partner
contributes deep expertise in quantum computing and federated learning, with access to state-of-the-art algorithmic
research and computational frameworks. The third partner contributes operational and regulatory insight, drawing on
direct experience with ATM stakeholders, industry bodies, and international regulators. This combination ensures
that the project not only develops and analyses conceptual frameworks, but also tests their plausibility in the context
of the real ATM system.
The consortium also has access to the infrastructures required for this work. The ATM research partner maintains
modelling platforms and reference datasets that support exploratory analysis in a SESAR context. The quantum
computing partner has access to qu antum simulators and federated learning frameworks suitable for conceptual
testing. The operational partner brings established stakeholder networks and access to policy and regulatory processes
that allow the project results to be evaluated in relation to real-world governance and adoption constraints. Together,
these infrastructures provide the project with all the tools needed for TRL 1 exploration.
=== PAGE 55 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 22 of 50
The partners complement one another across the research chain. The computing expertise ensures that new methods
are explored rigorously, the ATM research expertise ensures that methods are tested against relevant operational
questions, and the operational expertise ensures that outputs are credible for stakeholders and aligned with regulatory
processes. None of these alone would be sufficient; together they provide a coherent and proportionate team for the
project.
Cross-cutting considerations are also addressed. The consortium applies open science practices in line with Horizon
Europe requirements, including publication in open -access journals, sharing of analytical frameworks, and
compliance with FAIR data management principles. The project also acknowledges that the integration of the gender
dimension in R&I is not directly relevant to the scientific content, since the research addresses computational and
operational questions without differentiated gender impacts. However, dissemination and communication activities
will be inclusive, with attention to diversity in language, imagery, and stakeholder engagement.
Overall, the consortium is proportionate to the scale and ambition of QUANTAIR. It combines complementary
expertise in computing, ATM research, and operational regulation, has access to the required infrastructures, and is
well positioned to deliver the pr ojects objectives while preparing the ground for future SESAR research at higher
maturity levels.
#§CON-SOR-CS§# #§PRJ-MGT-PM§#
Tables for section 3.1
Table 3.1a: List of work packages
Work
package
No
Work Package
Title
Lead
Participant
No
Lead
Participant
Short Name
Person-
Months
Start
Month
End
month
1 Project
Management &
CDE
1 DLR 10 01 24
2 QUANTAIR
Research
Activity, Part A
2 Qoro 18 01 09
3 QUANTAIR
Research
Activity, Part B
2 Qoro 18 09 18
4 CDE Wrap-up 3 SkyNav 4 18 24
Table 3.1b: Work package description
For each work package:
Work package number 1
Work package title Project Management & CDE
=== PAGE 56 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 23 of 50
Objectives
This work package ensures that the project is managed efficiently and in full alignment with Horizon Europe
and SESAR 3 JU requirements. It provides governance, financial and administrative management, reporting,
and quality assurance across the project. I t also covers the planning and execution of communication,
dissemination, exploitation, and data management activities, ensuring that results are properly documented and
shared. In doing so, it establishes the framework for the projects visibility and impact, and leads directly into
the final CDE phase (WP4) where these activities are consolidated and completed.
The specific objectives are to:
1. Ensure effective project governance and coordination, including quality assurance and compliance
with SESAR 3 JU requirements.
2. Establish and maintain the projects management framework through delivery and updating of the
Project Management Plan (PMP), Data Management Plan (DMP), and related documentation.
3. Provide timely and accurate reporting, including periodic reports and preparation for SESAR reviews.
4. Plan and implement communication, dissemination, and exploitation activities, including the
Communication and Dissemination Plan (CDE), project website, online presence, and events.
5. Support long-term uptake and impact by drafting and finalising the exploitation and impact strategy,
ensuring compliance with open science and FAIR data requirements, and preparing the transition into
the final CDE wrap-up phase.
Description of work
Governance will be provided by a Project Management Board (PMB), chaired by the Coordinator and
composed of one representative from each partner. The PMB will meet quarterly to review progress, monitor
risks, and take decisions on both technical and admini strative issues. The Project Coordinator will manage
day-to-day operations and act as the primary interface with SESAR 3 JU. A Kick-off Meeting (KoM) in Month
1 will formally establish working procedures, confirm roles and responsibilities, and launch project activities.
A Project Management Plan (PMP) will be delivered in Month 3 to formalise procedures for governance,
reporting, quality assurance, and risk management. This will include internal review mechanisms to ensure
that all deliverables are technically sound, consistent, and aligned with SESAR standards before submission.
The PMP will be updated at mid -point (M12) to reflect lessons learned and adjustments. Progress will be
monitored continuously, with corrective measures applied promptly in case of deviations.
Research data will be managed under a Data Management Plan (DMP), produced in Month 3 and updated as
needed. The DMP will describe the types of data generated, their provenance, and how FAIR principles
(Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) will be applied. Where confidentiality or security constraints
apply, these will be documented with clear justification. Datasets and analytical outputs will be preserved in
trusted repositories with persistent identifiers to ensure long-term access.
The Communication, Dissemination and Exploitation (CDE) Plan will also be delivered in Month 3 and
updated at least once during the project (M12). It will define the channels and activities to ensure visibility and
uptake of results, including the project website, open -access publications, contributions to SESAR
dissemination events, and targeted outreach to scientific, operational, and policy audiences. A mid -project
dissemination event will be held at M12 to share initial results and prepare the ground for the final wrap -up
phase. WP1 therefore establishes the framework for CDE activities, while the final consolidation and impact
reporting are delivered in WP4.
Exploitation measures will focus on enabling results to be taken forward in future SESAR research and by
stakeholders such as ANSPs, regulators, and ICAO working groups. Intellectual property will be managed in
=== PAGE 57 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 24 of 50
line with Horizon Europe rules and the consortium agreement, with a principle of openness unless specific
protection is required to preserve exploitation potential. A draft post-research exploitation and impact strategy
will be delivered in M24, which then feeds into WP4 for finalisation and promulgation.
Reporting will cover all mandatory submissions to SESAR 3 JU, including periodic reports at the end of each
reporting period and the final project report at closure. SESAR review meetings will be treated as milestones
in project governance. The consortium will prepare collectively for these reviews, ensuring that deliverables,
presentations, and supporting evidence are complete and coherent. Internal review meetings will be scheduled
in advance to prepare for each review and ensure alignment with SESAR expectations.
Work package number 2
Work package title QUANTAIR Research Activity, Part A
Objectives
This work package establishes the conceptual and analytical foundations for applying Quantum Federated
Learning (QFL) in Air Traffic Management. It provides the first structured exploration of how QFL could be
framed within ATM constraints, how it might operate across distributed stakeholders, and what benefits or
limitations may arise in different operational contexts. The emphasis is on scoping and structuring the research,
and on producing verifiable outputs that are consistent with the TRL 1 nature of the project and suitable for
review at the end of the first reporting period.
The specific objectives are to:
1. Define the conceptual framework for QFL in ATM, including assumptions on data distribution,
privacy constraints, stakeholder behaviour, and computational resources.
2. Scope and characterise the four exploratory cases (PREDICT, HORIQON, SHIELD, CONTRADE),
identifying the ATM challenges they represent and their relevance to SESAR priorities.
3. Develop baseline analytical models for each case, using synthetic data and structured representations
of ATM processes to test conceptual feasibility.
4. Identify potential benefits, limitations, and open research questions arising from each case, recording
these in interim deliverables.
5. Produce a consolidated interim report that synthesises findings across all cases and highlights cross -
cutting requirements for advancing to TRL 23 research.
Description of work
The purpose of WP2 is to establish the conceptual and analytical basis of the project. The first nine months are
dedicated to scoping the research in a structured way, producing tangible outputs that allow progress to be
verified at the interim review. This reflects both the TRL 1 nature of QUANTAIR and the SESAR requirement
for clear evidence of achievement within the first reporting period. The work ensures that Quantum Federated
Learning is not treated as an abstract concept, but is defined in relation to the constraints and opportunities of
Air Traffic Management.
The work begins with the development of the conceptual framework for QFL in ATM. This framework sets
out the core assumptions on which the research is based, including the distribution and heterogeneity of data
sources, the privacy constraints that prevent raw data exchange, the behavioural preferences of stakeholders
=== PAGE 58 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 25 of 50
such as airlines cost -index settings, and the computational resources that can realistically be assumed at
different maturity levels. It also addresses governance considerations, such as how trust and participation are
established between stakeholders, and what indicators of feasibility can be applied at TRL 1. This step creates
the common reference point against which each exploratory case can be analysed.
Each of the four exploratory cases is then scoped in detail. For PREDICT, HORIQON, SHIELD, and
CONTRADE, the partners will describe the operational challenge, its connection to SESAR Master Plan
objectives, and the specific way in which QFL could apply. This scoping ensures that the project covers a
broad spectrum of ATM challenges (predictability, high -altitude integration, resilience, and environmental
optimisation) rather than variations on a single theme. It also defines for each case the boundaries of what can
be assessed at TRL 1, the types of data or models that would be relevant, and the expected indicators of benefit
or limitation.
Once the scoping is complete, baseline analytical models will be developed for each case. These models will
use synthetic data and structured representations of ATM processes, rather than operational datasets, to ensure
that the work remains feasible within a TRL 1 scope. The models are intended to test conceptual feasibility:
whether QFL can in principle represent the ATM dynamics involved, whether stakeholder constraints can be
incorporated in a distributed way, and whether potential benefits can be expressed in measurable terms. This
activity requires close collaboration between the partners: the quantum computing expertise to design federated
and distributed model structures, the ATM research expertise to represent operational processes, and the
operational expertise to validate the plausibility of assumptions.
Findings from the framework and case models will be captured continuously and compared across cases. This
cross-case analysis is a critical part of WP2: it ensures that common themes are identified, that lessons from
one case inform the others, and that ga ps and limitations are recorded in a way that can guide WP3. Interim
deliverables, including the Exploratory Research Plan (ERP), Exploratory Research Report (ERR), and
Concept Outlines, provide formal records of this work. These deliverables will undergo internal review and
PMB approval before submission to SESAR 3 JU, ensuring technical soundness and alignment with SESAR
standards.
Resource allocation in WP2 reflects the intensity of this phase. All three partners are engaged in parallel across
the four cases, with effort distributed according to expertise: ATM research leads the case scoping and
conceptual assumptions, the quantum partner leads federated modelling structures, and the operational partner
ensures realism, regulatory alignment, and tra ceability to stakeholder concerns. The effort in WP2 is
proportionately the largest, as it defines the trajectory for the remainder of the project and provides the evidence
required at the first review milestone.
By the end of WP2, the project will have established a conceptual framework for QFL in ATM, scoped and
modelled its application across four distinct operational contexts, and produced the first structured assessment
of feasibility. These outputs provide the foundation for refinement and integration in WP3, and allow SESAR
to judge progress at the interim stage with confidence that the project is on track.
Work package number 3
Work package title QUANTAIR Research Activity, Part B
Objectives
This work package builds directly on the foundations established in WP2. Whereas WP2 defined the
=== PAGE 59 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 26 of 50
conceptual framework and developed initial models for the exploratory cases, WP3 is focused on refinement,
cross-case synthesis, and the production of final research outputs. The emphasis is on consolidating results
into a coherent assessment of Quantum Federated Learning (QFL) in ATM, and on defining realistic pathways
for future research at higher maturity levels. WP3 therefore completes the scientific work of the project before
the CDE wrap-up phase begins.
The specific objectives are to:
1. Refine and extend the exploratory case models developed in WP2, incorporating lessons learned and
addressing the open questions identified in the first reporting period.
2. Conduct systematic cross-case analysis to identify common challenges, benefits, and limitations of
QFL across diverse ATM domains.
3. Develop structured recommendations for advancing QFL research towards TRL 2 3, including the
conditions under which quantum machine learning and other quantum methods could provide
additional value.
4. Produce a consolidated final research report that synthesises the projects findings, documents
conceptual advances, and defines priorities for future SESAR research.
5. Frame the results to support dissemination and exploitation, ensuring that outputs are relevant for
SESAR follow-on projects, ATM stakeholders, and international bodies such as ICAO and EASA.
Description of work
WP3 represents the second phase of the research activity and builds directly on the foundations established in
WP2. While the first nine months of the project are focused on scoping and baseline modelling, the following
nine months are dedicated to refinement, integration, and the delivery of the final research outputs. The aim is
to consolidate the work of the exploratory cases into a coherent assessment of Quantum Federated Learning in
ATM, and to provide recommendations and pathways for how this early-stage research can be taken forward
at higher maturity levels.
The work begins with refinement of the exploratory case models. Each case - PREDICT, HORIQON, SHIELD,
and CONTRADE - will be revisited using the frameworks and assumptions established in WP2. The baseline
models developed earlier will be extended to incorporate lessons learned, address gaps identified in the interim
review, and respond to stakeholder feedback where appropriate. Refinement may include adjusting
assumptions on data distribution or stakeholder behaviour, testing alternative formulations of the federated
learning approach, or clarifying the conditions under which conceptual feasibility is most evident. This ensures
that the case outputs are not static one -off analyses but part of an iterative process of validation and
improvement.
Once the case models have been refined individually, the consortium will conduct systematic cross -case
analysis. The purpose of this activity is to extract common themes and divergences across the four contexts.
For example, it may be that QFL appears most promising in situations where privacy constraints dominate (as
in SHIELD or CONTRADE), but less so where operational predictability is already supported by centralised
models (as in PREDICT). Cross -case analysis allows the consortium to identify these patterns, quantify
similarities and differences where possible, and derive generalisable insights. It also ensures that the project
delivers more than four separate case studies: the results are integrated into a broader understanding of where
QFL can contribute to ATM and where its limitations are most apparent.
In parallel, WP3 develops structured recommendations for the future. These recommendations will set out the
steps required to advance QFL research to TRL 2 3, including what kinds of datasets, computational tools,
and stakeholder collaborations will be needed. They will also identify where quantum optimisation and other
quantum computing methods could in future provide additional value, recognising that current hardware is not
=== PAGE 60 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 27 of 50
yet sufficient for operational validation but that pathways towards higher maturity can be mapped. The
recommendations will be positioned within the SESAR programme context, linking to Master Plan objectives
and ensuring coherence with European and international research agendas.
The culmination of WP3 is the production of the final consolidated research report. This document will
synthesise the projects findings, document the conceptual advances achieved, and set out the open questions
that remain. It will provide the first structured TRL 1 assessment of QFL in ATM, written in a way that supports
both technical follow -on research and policy -level consideration. The report will be accompanied by
consolidated concept outlines for each case, ensuring that results are clearly traceabl e and can be compared
across contexts.
The work in WP3 also contributes directly to dissemination and exploitation. By framing results in a way that
is relevant for SESAR follow -on projects, ATM stakeholders, and international bodies such as ICAO and
EASA, the outputs of WP3 are designed to be immediately useful beyond the project itself. This includes
highlighting potential contributions to international guidance documents (such as ICAOs GATMOC) and to
regulatory roadmaps such as the EASA AI and Higher Airspace Operations strategies.
The resources allocated to WP3 reflect the need for intensive collaborative work. All partners are fully
engaged: quantum computing expertise is used to refine federated modelling structures and assess long -term
scalability; ATM research expertise leads th e cross -case synthesis and ensures coherence with SESAR
frameworks; and operational and regulatory expertise ensures that recommendations are framed in a way that
is credible to stakeholders and aligned with the wider aviation ecosystem. WP3 therefore represents the point
where the strands of the project are brought together, refined, and translated into outputs that are not only
scientifically sound but also operationally meaningful.
By the end of WP3, the project will have moved from initial feasibility exploration to a consolidated set of
findings. The results will provide a clear picture of how QFL could contribute to ATM, what limitations must
be addressed, and what steps are required to move forward. This provides a natural transition into WP4, where
dissemination, exploitation, and open science compliance are finalised and the projects impact is secured.
Work package number 4
Work package title Post Research CDE Activity
Objectives
This work package consolidates and amplifies the results of the project, ensuring that the outputs of
QUANTAIR are visible, accessible, and usable for future research, regulatory processes, and operational
stakeholders. While CDE activities are initiated in WP1, the final phase provides dedicated focus o n
exploitation, open science compliance, and high -impact dissemination. WP4 demonstrates the consortiums
commitment to maximising the value of Horizon Europe and SESAR investment, by delivering results that are
technically credible, operationally relevant, and aligned with European and international aviation strategies.
The specific objectives are to:
1. Finalise the exploitation and impact strategy, translating project results into clear recommendations
for SESAR follow -on activities, national and European research agendas, and international bodies
such as ICAO and EASA.
2. Ensure compliance with open science and FAIR principles , producing a repository of project
outputs (reports, models, datasets, metadata) in trusted long-term archives with persistent identifiers.
3. Maximise dissemination to the research community , through open -access publications,
contributions to SESAR dissemination events, and active presence in scientific fora.
=== PAGE 61 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 28 of 50
4. Promote visibility towards operational and policy stakeholders , including ANSPs, airlines,
regulators, and industry, by framing project results in terms of operational feasibility, policy relevance,
and long-term research pathways.
5. Deliver a final public event and supporting materials, showcasing the projects achievements and
providing a platform for dialogue with the wider ATM community, demonstrating the value of SESAR
exploratory research and its contribution to the Digital European Sky vision.
Description of work
WP4 consolidates the results of the project and ensures that they are visible, accessible, and exploitable beyond
the lifetime of QUANTAIR. While communication, dissemination, and exploitation activities are initiated
under WP1 to give early visibility, th is final phase provides dedicated focus on maximising impact. The
emphasis is on producing a final exploitation and impact strategy, ensuring compliance with open science
principles, and delivering a high-quality public event that promotes the projects results to both technical and
policy audiences.
The first strand of work concerns the exploitation and impact strategy. A draft version is developed under
WP1, but in WP4 this is finalised based on the complete research results. The strategy translates conceptual
findings into concrete recommendations for SESAR follow-on activities, as well as guidance for national and
European research agendas. It also identifies how the results can support international bodies such as ICAO,
for example through inputs to the Global Air Traffic Management Operational Con cept (GATMOC), and
EASA, through alignment with the AI Roadmap and Higher Airspace Operations strategy. By framing the
results in terms of both research and policy pathways, the strategy ensures that QUANTAIR provides
maximum value to SESAR and the wider aviation community.
The second strand addresses open science and data preservation. A final repository of project outputs will be
prepared, ensuring that reports, conceptual models, metadata, and other analytical products are made available
in trusted long-term archives. All materials will carry persistent identifiers to guarantee findability and access,
and licensing conditions will be clearly stated to encourage reuse where possible. This ensures that the research
remains transparent and accessible, in line with the FAIR pri nciples (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable,
Reusable) and Horizon Europes open science obligations. Sensitive or restricted material will be clearly
documented, with justifications for any limitations on access.
The third strand is dissemination to the research community. Results will be submitted for publication in open-
access journals and conference proceedings, ensuring peer-reviewed visibility and providing a foundation for
subsequent academic and industrial r esearch. The consortium will also contribute to SESAR dissemination
events, workshops, and thematic fora, presenting QUANTAIR as a case study of how Horizon Europe
exploratory research can be used to investigate emerging concepts at TRL 1. This creates continuity with other
SESAR activities and supports the integration of results into the wider Digital European Sky programme.
A fourth strand focuses on visibility towards operational and policy stakeholders. While the research is
conceptual, its framing will be tailored to the concerns of ANSPs, airlines, regulators, and manufacturers.
Materials will highlight the operational implications of the findings, such as the handling of sensitive airline
preferences (e.g. cost index), or the potential for privacy-preserving collaboration on contrail avoidance. The
project will also prepare concise policy briefs, targeted at European institutions, to make the research outputs
accessible to decision-makers without requiring them to engage with technical detail.
Finally, WP4 delivers a high-impact final dissemination event. This event, organised at the end of the project,
will bring together the SESAR research community, operational stakeholders, and policy representatives. It
will showcase the projects achievements, present the consolidated results, and provide a forum for discussion
=== PAGE 62 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 29 of 50
on how QFL research should be taken forward. Supporting materials, including an event report, presentations,
and a digital archive of outputs, will ensure that the visibility of the project extends beyond the event itself.
The work in WP4 requires contributions from all partners. The ATM research partner ensures that the
exploitation strategy is aligned with SESAR frameworks. The quantum computing partner provides visibility
on how the conceptual work can evolve as technolog y matures. The operational partner ensures that
dissemination is framed in terms that resonate with industry and regulators. Together, the consortium ensures
that the final outputs are technically credible, operationally meaningful, and presented in a way that maximises
their uptake.
By the end of WP4, QUANTAIR will have delivered not only a comprehensive set of scientific results, but
also the supporting materials, strategies, and outreach activities needed to ensure that those results have impact.
The project will leave behind a transparent and accessible record of its findings, contribute to SESARs long-
term research programme, and demonstrate the role of Horizon Europe exploratory research in shaping the
future of ATM.
Table 3.1c: List of Deliverables
Nr. Deliverable
name Short description
Work
package
number
Short
name of
lead
participant
Type
Disse
minati
on
level
Delivery
date
(in
months)
1.1 KOM Report Report from the Kick-off
Meeting 1 DLR R PU 1
1.2 Initial PMP
Initial Project
Management Plan 1 DLR R PU 3
1.3 Initial CDE
Plan
Initial Communication,
Dissemination &
Exploitation plan
1 SkyNav R PU 3
1.4 Online
presence
Project Website and
Online presence 1 SkyNav DEC PU 3
1.5 Initial DMP Initial Data Management
Plan 1 DLR R PU 6
1.6 HE Report Periodic HE technical and
Financial report 1 Qoro R CO 9
1.7 Updated
PMP
Updated Project
Management Plan 1 DLR R PU 12
1.8 Updated
CDE Plan
Updated Communication,
Dissemination &
Exploitation plan
1 SkyNav R PU 12
1.9 Mid-project
Event
Information event about
research progress 1 SkyNav OTH PU 12
1.10 Updates
DMP
Updated Data
Management Plan 1 DLR R PU 15
1.11 Final project
report Final project report 1 DLR R CO 24
=== PAGE 63 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 30 of 50
2.1 Initial ERP Initial Exploratory
Research Plan 2 Qoro R PU 4
2.2 Initial ERR Initial Exploratory
Research Report 2 Qoro R PU 6
2.3 Initial CO Initial Concept Outline 2 Qoro R PU 6
3.1 Final ERP Final Exploratory Research
Plan 3 Qoro R PU 16
3.2 Final ERR Final Exploratory Research
Report 3 Qoro R PU 18
3.3 Final CO Final Concept Outline 3 Qoro R PU 18
4.1 Initial EI
Strategy
Initial Post-Research
Exploitation & Impact
Strategy
4 SkyNav R PU 20
4.2 Final EI
Strategy
Final Exploitation & Impact
Strategy 4 SkyNav R PU 24
4.3 Compliance
Report
Repository & Open Science
Compliance Report 4 SkyNav R PU 24
4.4 Final Event
Report
Final Promulgation Event
Report 4 SkyNav R PU 24
Table 3.1d: List of milestones
Milestone
number
Milestone name Related work
package(s)
Due date (in month) Means of verification
MS1.1 Project Governance
Established
1 1 PMB in place; KoM held;
PMP development
launched.
KoM report (D1.1).
MS1.2
Management and
CDE Frameworks
Approved
1 3 PMP, DMP, and initial
CDE Plan delivered and
accepted.
Submission of
D1.2/1.3/D1.5.
MS1.3
Mid-Project Review
Prepared
1 12 Updated PMP and CDE
delivered; Mid-project
event held.
Submission of D1.5D1.8.
MS1.4
Draft Exploitation &
Impact Strategy
Produced
1 18 Exploitation and impact
strategy delivered in draft,
ready for hand-over to
WP4.
Submission of D1.10.
MS1.5
Final Review &
Project Closure
1, 4 24 Final project report
delivered; SESAR final
review completed.
Acceptance of D1.9
D1.10.
=== PAGE 64 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 31 of 50
Table 3.1e: Critical risks for implementation #@RSK-MGT-RM@#
Description of risk (indicate level of
(i) likelihood, and (ii) severity:
Low/Medium/High)
Work package(s)
involved
Proposed risk-mitigation measures
R1. QFL concept does not yield
meaningful insights at TRL 1
(Likelihood: Medium; Severity: High).
Interim models show no plausible
feasibility signals across exploratory
cases.
WP2 WP3 Treat inconclusive or negative results as
valid TRL 1 outcomes; ensure each case
has at least two formulations so
alternatives can be tested; document
limits clearly and extract learning for
future TRL 23 work.
R2. Assumptions and frameworks
diverge between cases leading to
inconsistent or incomparable results
(Likelihood: Medium; Severity:
Medium).
WP2 WP3
Maintain a common framework agreed
in D2.1; record all assumptions in an
“assumptions register” reviewed by
PMB; hold cross-partner review sessions
before submitting deliverables.
R3. Baseline models cannot capture
distributed ATM constraints
realistically (privacy, governance,
airline cost-index preferences)
(Likelihood: Medium; Severity:
Medium).
WP2 Start with simplified synthetic scenarios;
expand gradually; involve operational
experts early; record limitations
explicitly in interim reports.
R4. Exploratory cases overlap too
much, reducing distinct insights
(Likelihood: Medium; Severity:
Medium).
WP2 WP3
Enforce differentiation when scoping
cases; PMB validates distinct objectives
for each; adjust case emphasis if overlap
is detected.
R5. Over-reliance on synthetic data
reduces credibility of results
(Likelihood: Medium; Severity:
Medium).
WP2 WP3
Anchor synthetic datasets to published
SESAR references; use sensitivity
analyses to show robustness; invite
stakeholder feedback at mid-project
event.
R6. Role of quantum computing is
overstated or too vague (Likelihood:
Medium; Severity: High).
WP2 WP3
Link all quantum-related statements to
clear conditions of validity; maintain a
“claims register”; ensure internal peer
review of evidence before submission.
R7. Limited stakeholder engagement
reduces visibility and uptake
(Likelihood: Low; Severity: Medium).
WP1 WP4
Use consortium networks across ATM,
regulatory, and research communities;
organise mid-project and final events;
publish open-access outputs and policy
briefs.
R8. Unavailability of key staff due to
illness, turnover, or conflicting
commitments (Likelihood: Medium;
Severity: Medium).
WP1 WP2 WP3 WP4
Redistribute effort across the consortium
where possible, using flexibility in the
Horizon Europe rules; adjust timelines
for lower-priority tasks to protect critical
deliverables; replace staff within the
same partner if necessary, ensuring
continuity of expertise.
#§RSK-MGT-RM§#
=== PAGE 65 ===
Call: [HORIZON-SESAR-2023-DES-ER3] — [Digital European Sky Exploratory Research 03]
EU Grants: Application form (HE RIA and IA)( HORIZON-SESAR-2025-DES-ER-03): V4.0 18.12.2024
Part B - Page 32 of 50
Table 3.1f: Summary of staff effort
WP1 WP2 WP3 WP4 Total Person-
Months per Participant
1/DLR 5 5 5 1 16
2/Qoro 6 14 12 3 35
3/SkyNav 11.8 6 6 4 27.8
Total Person Months 22.8 25 23 8 78.8
Table 3.1h: Purchase costs items (travel and subsistence, equipment and other goods, works and
services)
1/DLR
Cost (€) Justification
Travel and subsistence 5000 Travel for conferences, workshops, and team meetings
Equipment -
Other goods, works and
services
-
Remaining purchase costs
(<15% of pers. Costs)
-
Total 5000
2/Qoro
Cost (€) Justification
Travel and subsistence 12500 Travel for conferences, workshops, and team meetings
Equipment -
Other goods, works and
services
2000 Consortia events, venue and facilities
Remaining purchase costs
(<15% of pers. Costs)
-
Total 12500
3/SkyNav
Cost (€) Justification
Travel and subsistence 17500 Travel for conferences, workshops, and team meetings
Equipment -
Other goods, works and
services
-
Remaining purchase costs
(<15% of pers. Costs)
-
Total 17500
#§QUA-LIT-QL§# #§WRK-PLA-WP§#
=== PAGE 66 ===
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
This electronic receipt is a digitally signed version of the document submitted by your
organisation. Both the content of the document and a set of metadata have been digitally
sealed.
This digital signature mechanism, using a public -private key pair mechanism, uniquely
binds this eReceipt to the modules of the Funding & Tenders Portal of the European
Commission, to the transaction for which it was generated and ensures its full integr ity.
Therefore a complete digitally signed trail of the transaction is available both for your
organisation and for the issuer of the eReceipt.
Any attempt to modify the content will lead to a break of the integrity of the electronic
signature, which can b e verified at any time by clicking on the eReceipt validation
symbol.
More info about eReceipts can be found in the FAQ page of the Funding & Tenders
Portal.
(https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/support/faq)